Caught Stealing – Review and Summary
Caught Stealing, despite not being a mystery, is a twisty ride which respects you enough to keep things interesting without something coming out of left field.
Spoiler Alert: This summary and review contains spoilers.
Additionally, some images and text may include affiliate links, meaning we may earn a commission or receive products if you make a purchase.
“Caught Stealing” Film Details
- Runtime: 1 Hour(s) and 47 Minutes
- Released On: In Theaters
- Public Release Date: August 29, 2025
- Director(s): Darren Aronofsky
- Writer(s): Charlie Huston
- Based On Work By: Charlie Huston
- Primary Language: English
- Genre(s): Comedy, Crime, Thriller
- Rating: Rated R
- Distributor: Columbia Pictures
- Official Site Link
Movie Summary
Hank is a small-town boy from California who, after an injury ended his baseball career, moved to New York City. He works as a bartender to make ends meet, hangs out with his girlfriend Yvonne when she isn’t working as a paramedic, and occasionally speaks to his neighbor Russ.
But thanks to this association with Russ, Hank’s life goes to hell, and considering all the issues and trauma he left behind in California, or at least he thought he did, it seems New York City might be ruined for him, too.
Cast and Characters
Hank (Austin Butler)
- Check out other productions we’ve covered starring this actor: [Link to Actor’s Tag]
- Character Summary: At one time, Hank’s mom trained him up to be an MLB player. However, one incident ended his baseball career, and since then, he has moved to New York City, become a bartender, and taken to drinking to drown away what could have been and maybe what he is now.
Yvonne (Zoë Kravitz)
- Check out other productions we’ve covered starring this actor: [Link to Actor’s Tag]
- Character Summary: Yvonne is a paramedic, born and raised in New York, who is dating Hank, but questions how serious he is about not only their relationship, and its future, but his own.
Russ (Matt Smith)
- Check out other productions we’ve covered starring this actor: [Link to Actor’s Tag]
- Character Summary: Russ is Hank’s English neighbor, often in punk rock clothes, who is into some illegal activities.
Detective Roman (Regina King)
- Check out other productions we’ve covered starring this actor: [Link to Actor’s Tag]
- Character Summary: Like Yvonne, Detective Roman is born and raised in New York but is far more vocal about her love/hate relationship with the city. She works there, lives there, grew up there, but plans to retire in Tulum, for what it takes to survive in the city is becoming a bit much.
Other Noteworthy Information
- It’s 1998 in the movie
What To Expect In “Caught Stealing” (Rated R) – Content Overview
- Dialog:
- Cursing: Throughout
- Violence:
- Gun Violence: Full-On Battles
- Violence Against Animals: Yes (Context: The cat isn’t exempt from the violence)
- Gore/ Blood/ Body Horror: Bleeding, Depiction of Open Wounds
- Notable Violence: Torture, Intense Fight Scenes
- Sexual Content:
- Nudity: Tantalizing | Chest
- Sexual Situations: Implied
- Miscellaneous:
- Drinking: Yes
- Drug Use: Recreational
- Vomiting: Yes
- Smoking: Yes
Review and Commentary
Highlight(s)
It’ll Keep You Guessing Regarding How It Will End [87/100]
The majority of Caught Stealing feels like it wants to be rooted in the idea of the worst-case scenario happening to Hank, without losing some sense of realism. It wants you to understand Hank has PTSD from something that happened in his teens, so his grip on his life is that of someone grasping at straws to have a reason to live. Yvonne is meant to be his silver lining, but with him stuck in the past, she rightfully questions their future, and then there is the Russ situation.
In many ways, what Russ drops into Hank’s life tests everything he has built up in the last decade in New York, six years in his current community. Not just in terms of whether Yvonne will stick around as Russian and Jewish mobsters threaten Hank’s life, but whether he still is that nice small-town boy who decided to move to the big city. If Hank does have the relationships needed to weather beat downs, the threats of being tortured and murdered, never mind how he’ll handle Russ if he lives to see him again.
Each day of Caught Stealing, which covers less than two weeks, leaves you wondering how this will end for Hank? Who will die as he just as much tries to avoid what Russ left him with, as he is pushed to find what everyone thinks he has access to? Will he live to have a happy ending, a bittersweet one, or will he make the wrong alliance, be overconfident, and get himself killed?
By no means is Caught Stealing trying to have a bunch of twists and turns like a detective movie, but it does leave room for anything to be possible in ways that keep you actively engaged.
On The Fence
How It Depicts Hank’s Trauma Is Shown But Not Often Felt [78/100]
Throughout the movie, it is made clear that an accident that happened in California, more than a decade ago, haunts Hank. Then, add in what happens throughout the movie, and it adds to his trauma, making it so he often wakes up gasping, like every time he goes to sleep, he didn’t expect to wake up.
In explaining this, you may think Hank is really going through it, and it adds weight to the movie and Butler’s performance, but it doesn’t. We see Hank drinks a lot to manage, and it is starting to weigh on his relationship. But Caught Stealing isn’t geared to be a drama in tone. It walks that thin line of having enough character development to give Hank some kind of depth, but wanting things light enough so that this can be seen as a dark comedy.
This ultimately can make Hank’s guilt and trauma feel downplayed a bit, even as the movie violently depicts what haunts him when he closes his eyes too long.
Overall
Our Rating (82/100): Positive (Worth Seeing)
Caught Stealing is the perfect end-of-summer movie. It combines popular faces and names with a story that doesn’t feel conventional, and bundles that together into something that can feel more memorable than most of what you watched this season.
Video Text
- Intro Slide
- Summary: Hank moved from California to New York City after his baseball career ended tragically, but at least he has found friends, community, and Yvonne in New York.
- Summary: However, one of those friends, his neighbor Russ, drags him into nonsense, which includes the Russian mafia, Jewish gangsters, and more.
- Summary: Hank does his best to keep from getting too involved, or the situation escalating, but Russ is MIA and everyone thinks Hank knows something – and is willing to threaten and torture him.
- Summary: Leaving him with no choice but to try to gain some form of leverage, some means to get everyone off his back, before he ends up on his back, face up, six feet under.
- Review: Caught Stealing is one of the few films you may watch that can keep you guessing a bit, for it makes the villains back up every threat with an action.
- Review: Because of this, people die, and as Austin Butler gets you invested in Hank, Zoe Kravitz with Yvonne, and others showcase their talent, you are worried about who is going to live or die.
- Review: And I want to give a special note that Regina King – She ties it all together so beautifully as Detective Roman.
- Review: But I will say, how the film handles Hank’s trauma that led him to leave California is very much hit or miss.
- Review: You get that he has PTSD, but Caught Stealing doesn’t allow Butler to go as far as needed to turn an explanation of what led him to NYC into something that could stir your feelings.
- Overall (82/100): Caught Stealing should become that sleeper August hit, for when studios released all their blockbusters and then a film comes out of nowhere to end the summer on a good note.
What To Check Out Next
Check out our movies page for our latest movie reviews and recommendations.
-
Swimming With Sharks: Season 1 – Summary/ Review (with Spoilers)
Relying on star power than substance, Swimming with Sharks is entertaining but won’t be a killer property for Roku.
-
Mr. Villain’s Day Off: Season 1 – Episode Recaps & Review
In this post, you’ll find summaries of the episodes of Mr. Villain’s Day Off: Season 1, and what we thought were the highlights, low points, on-the-fence topics, and notable parts of the season.
-
What Happens In The Dark (2023) – Review and Summary
“What Happens In The Dark” shows some signs it could have been interesting, but instead, it is lukewarm thanks to a lack of information about what’s going on, how we got here, and who is dishing out the consequences.
