As one guest ventures through history and another confronts themselves, we see mirror images of what Elena and Ruby are dealing with.

Alongside Prosper’s daughter coming to St. Jo, we meet who Aunt Vi has been keeping a secret, learn the gender of Ralph Angel and Darla’s baby, and more.

It’s time for another elimination, but not before The Circle allows people to anonymously review each other, thus causing some drama.

It is decided who is the real and who is the fake, and soon after, we end up with two new players, who are both catfishes.

Daniel’s final days are shown, as we also get to know why his death affected Elora so much.

As a group of friends conquer their 50th birthday and the long-gestating issues of their friendship, Elena and Ruby face some long-held fears.

With one shock after another, The Voyeurs deserves to be part of a group movie night so you and your friends can share your reactions in real-time.

With their identity stolen, frustration and desperation start to hit, and hearing how well the imposter is doing makes you fear who might get kicked.

Though usually “What If?” episodes are saved for later seasons, Mr. Corman decides to do theirs in their freshman season with 8+ scenarios.