Spoiler Alert: This summary and review contains spoilers.
Additionally, some images and text may include affiliate links, meaning we may earn a commission or receive products if you make a purchase.
“Other Mommy” Film Details
- Director(s): Rob Savage
- Writer(s): Nathan Elston
- Based On Work By: Josh Malerman
- Source Material: Incidents Around the House
- Runtime: 1 Hour(s) and 33 Minutes
- Public Release Date (In Theaters): October 9, 2026
- Genre(s): Drama, Horror, Thriller
- Content Rating: Rated R
Movie Summary
Bela is prepping for another school year, as are her parents for their next wedding anniversary. However, it quickly becomes clear that something is off. Bela seems to have an imaginary friend, who is a little frightening, dubbed “Other Mommy” and it seems they know something Bela doesn’t, and wants to protect her from the truth.
However, Bela thinks everything is fine between her parents, Ursula and Russ. But considering the form the demon takes on, that should be the biggest hint that Ursula is hiding something from everyone.
Cast and Characters
- Bela (Arabella Olivia Clark)
- Ursula (Jessica Chastain)
- Russ (Jay Duplass)
Review and Commentary
Highlight(s)
Other Mommy Can Be Genuinely Creepy [81/100]
At times, it was hard to say what drew Other Mommy to Bela. We’re told it is the innocence of a child, but why become the parent she doesn’t have the closest relationship with? It instantly makes things creepy, and the body horror the film uses pushes things to give you the creeps.
Now, could the film have taken it further, and really pushed Other Mommy’s goals of being let into Bela’s heart, or taking advantage of a vulnerable family? Yes. But, even without furthering how easy it could have been to exploit everyone, there is enough here to give you a slight grimacing look while watching.
A Drama With Horror Elements [82/100]
Other Mommy honestly could be stripped of its horror elements and still work as a film. At its heart is a family where the parents are trying to make their relationship work, but you can tell both are unhappy. This is why it can sometimes seem like Other Mommy is a manifestation of the negative emotions no one talks about, but Bela senses is there.
Ursula, who works all the time, seems potentially worried about money, maybe hates being a mom, and is using work to keep from spending time with Bela – who knows? Then with Russ, he is a stay-at-home dad or gets to work from home, and this means taking on the heavy load of raising a kid. Which isn’t to imply Bela is made to seem difficult at all. However, it can feel like there was a compromise made for Bela to exist, and Ursula may try to will herself into enjoying motherhood, but perhaps can’t?
A lot of horror movies feature unhappy families, but I feel like Other Mommy really decided to explore those feelings rather than simply use them to setup the demon having something to work with. Leaving you with a movie that seemed to understand how to implement horror to further the family’s dissonance rather than tack on horror elements because it would lead to better ticket sales.
On The Fence
How Does This Family Stand A Chance? [73/100]
While Other Mommy is shown to be a being who prefers the shadows, it is also an entity that can mimic people, warp reality, physically fight, and is capable of great violence. Explain to me how anyone in this family was supposed to survive that? Never mind, for part of the movie, it seems to be holding back. So when it decides to not do so, and little if anything seems capable of truly hurting it, seeing this family try to fight back, and at times hold off Other Mommy, felt like they weakened it just to keep the story going.
Overall
Our Rating (78/100): Mixed (Divisive)
Other Mommy is enjoyable if you’re willing to let go that this is not going to be as scary or creepy as the trailer advertises. It’s far more a family drama, with this demon preying on the family, because its dysfunction leaves the child insecure, vulnerable, and an easy target.
What To Check Out Next
Check out our movies page! There you’ll find our latest movie reviews and recommendations.
-
Ash (2025) Review
While there is a certain beauty to “Ash” it maybe questionable if it has the substance you’d want or expect.
-
Sinister Surgeon (2024) – Written Review
Starring Samantha Neyland Trumbo, we watch as a highly educated surgical resident joins a practice marred by a burgeoning scandal of recent patients being murdered.
-
Fear Street (Part 3) – 1666 – Review/Summary (with Spoilers)
Fear Street: Part 3 (1666) is the perfect ending to the horror trilogy and will make you hope more trilogies resolve as quickly as this one did.
Images used for editorial and commentary purposes. All rights remain with their respective copyright holders.
