Reasonable Doubt: Season 4 Episode 1 – Who Got Shot?

Three months have passed, and with that comes new threats, newly introduced clients, and the answer to: Who got hit by Monica’s bullets?

ByAmari Allah Hours Posted on

Spoiler Alert: This summary and review contains spoilers.

Additionally, some images and text may include affiliate links, meaning we may earn a commission or receive products if you make a purchase.

Episode 1 “Dead Or Alive” Details

  • Director(s): Anton Cropper
  • Writer(s): Raamla Mohamed Hunter, Morgan A. Grain
  • Public Release Date (Hulu): October 6, 2026
  • Check out more of our “Reasonable Doubt” coverage.

Recap

The answer is Jax. She got shot, with the bullet coming out near her spine, and this sends Lewis for a loop. He has Mama Lu and Shanelle handle the kids and mainly stays at Jax’s side. The only time he doesn’t is for a drink with Sally’s ex, who is the one person who pushes the idea that maybe Lewis should focus on himself.

But you know Reasonable Doubt has no interest in Lewis being established as an individual, so that storyline dies quickly and before you know it, Jax is awake with the next question being: What’s the long-term damage? Not just to her, but to her firm.

You see, Corey steps in, but Jax’s morals are a bit more gray than Corey’s, and when it comes to Jax’s top client, Eric Cropper, a big-time music mogul who is very raw in how he talks, Corey tries to create distance. His attitude is that not all money is good money, even if Eric alone could float the firm. Also, mind you, three months passed, and Jax saved enough for the firm to last only six months unless a good amount of revenue came in.

What doesn’t help is that Bill and Jax’s ex-partners are trying to poach everyone, and while he feels bad about it, or at least says he does to Sally, it is hard to say if that’s the truth. The only thing we know for sure is Eric is the big fish, Jax is awake by the end of the episode, and Orsel’s mom, Rosie, blames Jax for Orsel’s death and is more than willing to finance Monica’s legal defense if it means getting back at Jax one way or another.

New Characters in Episode 1

Eric Cropper (Tank) in Reasonable Doubt Season 4 Episode 1
  • Eric Cropper (Tank)

Review and Commentary

Highlights

Not Extending Jax’s Time In a Coma [84/100]

Jax is what makes or breaks this show, and it became clear with her being in a coma for the majority of it. Yes, many of her co-stars have led shows or are big parts in ones still active, but when it comes to Reasonable Doubt, it lives and breathes based on what Jax is or is not doing.

Case in point, Lewis’ character is completely built around her. Corey, as talented as he is as a lawyer, has some sort of moral standards, which makes him boring, especially regarding a client like Eric. And considering Jax cares more about whether the client can pay than whether what she is doing is right or wrong, that is the driving force behind this show.

Because what else is the hook here?

On The Fence

Rosie Paying For Monica’s Defense [74/100]

I’m torn between not letting Orsel’s death be something to sweep under the rug, never mind Monica shooting Jax, like past cases or incidents we’ve seen. But I do hope, like Toni’s lawsuit and storyline from season 3, this is an active storyline but also one that gets handled quickly. For in comparison to what Eric brings to the show, this shouldn’t be on equal footing. It should be a B-Storyline to wrap up the plot from season 3.

The Excitement For What’s To Come [75/100]

As much as Eric could lead to a series of interesting situations, because he seems like he could murder his wife and a slew of other options, I got to admit, I’m more loyal to the show than excited to see what happens. Which, granted, could be why they released three episodes to start off the season rather than just one.

But doesn’t it feel wrong, even in the streaming era, to know one episode wouldn’t be enough so you have to release three? That you can’t really make the premiere pop, so you need to provide three to reassure fans this season will be good; we just can’t make that clear without laying a full-fledged foundation for the season first.

And to be fair, with how much drama Reasonable Doubt usually has, trying to pack too much in the premiere could lead to its own criticism. Pacing has always been a bit funky with this show. However, we’re four seasons in, and it still can feel like the show is trying to get its rhythm.

Overall

Our Overall Rating [77/100]

The return of Reasonable Doubt doesn’t feel as notable as it should, considering its lead got shot. But I would consider the reason for that is that this is by no means an ensemble, and no character is built to exist outside of Jax’s orbit. So her existing in a few flashbacks, and being in a coma for most of the episode, took away from what makes this show great. Even if, in her absence, the foundation for this season was being carefully built, so Jax could hit the ground running once out of the hospital.

What To Check Out Next

Visit our main TV shows page! There you’ll find other shows we’ve covered.

TV Shows We’re Covering This Season

Images used for editorial and commentary purposes. All rights remain with their respective copyright holders.

Listed Under Categories:
Related Tags: , , , , , , ,

Amari is the founder and head writer of Wherever-I-Look.com and has been reviewing media since 2010. He approaches each production with hope, rooting for every story to succeed, and believes criticism should come from unmet potential, while praise is reserved for work that meets or exceeds expectations.