Remy (Jenna Ortega) and Barnes (Percy Hynes White)
Remy (Jenna Ortega) and Barnes (Percy Hynes White)

Read our Editorial Guidelines regarding how posts are written and rated and our use of affiliate links.

Plot Summary

Despite going to the same school, Remy and Barnes have been strangers. However, after seeing her across from his friend’s house while smoking, Barnes takes an interest and takes advantage of seeing her again on a train to New York.

Initially, she isn’t interested since she and her family have plans for her to go to Harvard and become a lawyer, and she has committed to this since 5th grade. But Barnes is charming and nice, and while he isn’t as ambitious, for a time, she thought she could just hang out. However, as time goes on and her grip on her feelings and life loosens, so comes the question of whether room can be made for Barnes or if he should be treated as a dalliance.

Cast and Characters

Character’s Name Actor’s Name
Barnes Percy Hynes White
Remy Jenna Ortega


A military brat, Barnes isn’t sure what’s next for him in life but is sure he loves music, especially local bands, and having a good time.

  • The actor is also known for their role in “My Old Ass.”


Since she was 5, college, Harvard in particular, has been what Remy was molded for. By 5th grade, to know Remy is to know her college ambitions, and from a Google recognition to her studying habits, it seemingly has made her gain this mysterious mystique and has left her slightly isolated.


Our Rating: Positive (Worth Seeing)Recommended

Good If You Like

  • Young Adult romances

Similar To This

  1. Surprised By Oxford
  2. All Summers End
  3. Which Brings Me To You

Check out our movies page for our latest movie reviews and recommendations.



Between watching this and “My Old Ass,” it’s clear that Percy has the makings of becoming a heartthrob. Granted, credit has to be given to Dan Schoffer for the script, but you can’t discount the boy next door appeal, the slightest of hesitation, even when taking the initiative, and the overall feeling that, as bold as he might be, there is always the possibility of rejection.

It leads to a unique charm that fits the perceptions of Gen Z being more cautious in dating while reminding us that, often, for something to happen, the guy had to make the first move.

The Challenge Of Young Love’s Timing

Your late teens, the end of high school, is a huge jump. Your life and schedule have been controlled by your parents and your school, and now you find yourself thrust to take the reins as if your biggest responsibility thus far wasn’t taking out the trash or watching a family member, at least in the case of Remy and Barnes.

So imagine the sudden ability to control your life. Will you move from New Jersey to Boston for Harvard? What about this boy? If he can take a gap year, why can’t you? What about volunteering in Costa Rica? The madness of your first love, your first major decision, taking on debt as a long-term investment in yourself to set up the foundation for potentially the rest of your life? It’s a lot.

Acknowledging this allows you to give grace and understanding as Barnes and Remy make decisions that, as an adult, may seem inane, but for them, it can make sense. After all, as often quoted by us from a Refinery 29 interview with Rowan Blanchard:

“[…] we forget that when you’re a teenager, everything is literally happening for the first time. Growing up is dramatic! It’s emotional, it’s sad, and it’s really amazing.”

It’s Rooted In Middle/Upper Middle-Class Reality

One of the things we appreciate the most with “Winter Spring Summer or Fall” is that it isn’t over the top. Specifically, while Remy and Barnes come from what looks like a suburban, potentially affluent neighborhood, neither are rich. They aren’t 17 or 18, driving a BMW, going on expensive dates to the fanciest restaurants, or anything like that. Are they privileged? Yes. How many teens can say they have access to a friend’s lake house for the 4th of July weekend, with no parents there and lots of alcohol?

Yet, even with those privileges, between how committed Remy is to her life and career and you seeing Barnes clearly being someone who just doesn’t want a miserable life, what you see feels real and makes it all the easier to sit back and enjoy.

Background Information

Film Length 1 Hour 37 Minutes
Date Released June 7, 2024
Distributor Film Festival – Tribeca Festival
Director(s) Tiffany Paulsen
Writer(s) Dan Schoffer
Based On Work By N/A
Genre(s) RomanceYoung Adult
Content Rating Rated R
Content Information
Dialog Cursing
Violence Blood
Sexual Content N/A
Miscellaneous Drinking

Listed Under Categories: , , ,

Follow, Like and Subscribe

User Review
4.67 (3 votes)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.