Reasonable Doubt: Season 4 Episode 3 – You Are Who You Associate With

As the question of what Eric is capable of grows, Brooke’s criticism of Jax being an enabler leads to the question of how much she and her employees will tolerate to make money.

ByAmari Allah Hours Posted on

[Unless Said Otherwise] Spoiler Alert: This summary and review contains spoilers.

Additionally, some images and text may include affiliate links, meaning we may earn a commission or receive products if you make a purchase.

Episode 3 “Ain’t No Love (In the Heart of the City)” Details

  • Director(s): Cierra “Shooter” Glaudé
  • Writer(s): Ryan Richmond
  • Public Release Date (Hulu): October 6, 2026
  • Check out more of our “Reasonable Doubt” coverage.

Recap

Following the events of episode 2, we’re left to wonder not only what happened to Brooke, but also whether Eric set this up or not. Lest we forget, his persona is that of an R&B crooner, but behind closed doors he is anything but a loverman. So with that in mind, could he have had Brooke kidnapped? Could this all be an elaborate way to have her killed?

It’s honestly hard to say, but by the end of the episode, despite it seeming like Brooke was killed, she is at a police station accusing Eric of attempted murder. Though maybe Brooke arranged this herself, knowing how difficult it would be to challenge Eric while Jax represented him. If so, she may have felt she had to take extreme measures.

But that’s the thing about associating with men like Eric and women like Jax. As Regina tells Krystal, who is one of her students, there are different types of lawyers, and each decides their boundaries. Jax, while well respected, isn’t outright called out or criticized, but Regina subtly tries to convey to Krystal that Jax’s way isn’t the only way and may not be the best way.

Now, whether Krystal heeds this advice is hard to say, but she does note she is learning from Jax by observation, not direct tutelage. So maybe she may take note of Jax’s failings and be better or just steal her playbook? The only thing we know for sure is, as Jax continues to struggle with the psychological and physical damage Monica has done, she is starting to take more and more Oxy. Not to the point of needing to suspect if she is an addict, but enough to wonder if that might be a future storyline.

Other Noteworthy Information

  • Spenser is still trying to manage his mom being shot and Ozzie’s death
  • It’s confirmed one of the many White women Eric surprisingly has working for him is having an affair with him
  • Allegedly, Eric, or at the very least his record label, is heavily in debt

New Characters in Episode 3

  • Melina aka Mel (Alani “La La” Anthony)
  • Desiree Grant (Rutina Wesley)

Review and Commentary

Highlights

Krystal Removing The Rose Colored Glasses [83/100]

I appreciate the complication of Regina’s position. She is trying Jax’s case, is a peer, but also recognizes Jax is a legend in the making. Yet, at the same time, she potentially doesn’t support how Jax’s legend continues to grow and worries that Krystal could follow in her footsteps. It’s a tightrope between trying to open Krystal’s eyes but, at the same time, not wanting Jax to think she is poisoning Krystal’s opinion of her. After all, Krystal works for Jax, and clearly that is where her loyalties lie.

However, with Reasonable Doubt stating character goals but not consistently building up character complexity, having Krystal go from just looking at Jax as a successful lawyer and idolizing her to really taking note of what Jax is willing to do for her success should be interesting. Especially if it leads to her realizing she doesn’t want to be like Jax, and her potentially questioning if she is doing more harm than good. Though, on the flip side, there could also be Jax realizing Krystal may go further than she is willing to go, which could cause conflict.

Either way, there is more potential for Krystal’s storyline than there has been in a long time.

Corey and Brandy’s Relationship [83.5/100]

There is something about Corey and Brandy. Yes, things are complicated because of Corey potentially having feelings for Jax. However, there is something about Corey remaining engaged with Brandy, even as she challenges him or seeks to understand him, which is appealing. For, let’s be real here, finding healthy relationships between two Black people in scripted media can be difficult, especially at this budget and accessibility level. So for them to talk, be vulnerable, intimate, and not show any notable signs of being toxic – that, sadly, feels major.

I just hope it lasts.

On The Fence

Eric As The Lead Case [73/100]

Our issue with Eric is he lacks the complexity of Jax’s main client from season 2, in Shanelle, and season 3, in Ozzie. Eric is just a guy you love to hate, and as much as you can see him being an example of Jax putting money over morality, is that enough? Is him, potentially, trying to kill his wife over money enough to keep him interesting? Him cheating on his wife with potentially one of the many White women he has around?

To me, it isn’t. Eric seems more like a guest star who should pop up every now and again than be Jax’s main focus. For while there is a lot of personality there, I don’t think we need another character who survives mainly on that.

Hoping Reasonable Doubt Isn’t Going To Stop Mimicking The Chi In Casting Recognizable Faces And Underutilizing Them [74/100]

Reasonable Doubt is now one of the handful of active dramas, which have predominantly Black characters, on streaming/TV. With the end of The Chi, and P-Valley ending with its third season, it might be one of the most prolific that are still going. The beauty of that is, whether a newcomer or someone like Lala with an established career, it means you can get your start on a show which has a “For us, by us” attitude and vibe.

But the problem is, what we don’t want to see is the show adding a recognizable face vs. having a purpose for their talent. Because, as noted above, while Eric is useful, he isn’t necessarily holding the same weight as clients in the past who felt noteworthy. We don’t get any sense of gray or complication, as we did in season 2 or season 3. It’s far more about who is playing Eric, and what they are saying, than anything else.

Overall

Our Overall Rating [78/100]

With the three-episode premiere completed, I can say this: Reasonable Doubt still has the core thing that makes it interesting in Jax. It still is not consistently developing supporting characters to stand on their own, and when it comes to Eric? At best, he might be a catalyst.

He may help trigger Krystal to look at Jax in a new light, especially as she continues to go to school and realizes how Jax does her job. Also, Eric could further reveal how Jax is seen by her peers, like Regina, who aren’t so focused on becoming wealthy as they are on getting justice.

But overall, it is a challenge to get genuinely excited for what may come next, as what is being teased may push guest stars like Eric, who are already losing their luster, beyond their usefulness.

What To Check Out Next

Visit our main TV shows page! There you’ll find other shows we’ve covered.

TV Shows We’re Covering This Season

Images used for editorial and commentary purposes. All rights remain with their respective copyright holders.

Listed Under Categories:
Related Tags: , , , , , , ,

Amari is the founder and head writer of Wherever-I-Look.com and has been reviewing media since 2010. He approaches each production with hope, rooting for every story to succeed, and believes criticism should come from unmet potential, while praise is reserved for work that meets or exceeds expectations.