Serena looking out a window.

One Comment

  1. The series seems to be really pushing the idea that Serena is worthy of pity and capable of redemption. They’ve made two very big changes from the character in the novel, one which makes their job easier and one which makes their job harder.

    In the book, Serena was not directly involved in the rise of Gilead. Before the fundies took over, she was a singer, talk show host and televangelist. Although she preached a return to “traditional family values” as part of her schtick, her work wasn’t in any way connected to the Sons Of Jacob organisation and she was totally ignorant of their plans. She had no say in their design and was just as shocked as the protagonist when America became Gilead, though her wholesome public image meant she was better treated than most once the fundies took over. It is ambiguous in the book when exactly she married Fred… but in the TV series, she knew about The Fundies taking over from the beginning and had a say in the strategy to bring down the US government, even if she didn’t contribute any ideas to the structure of the new society that’d be created. This raises the bar much higher for Serena being redeemed… the Serena of the novel was just guilty of muttering vague Christian-conservative platitudes on TV, and then being less than enthusiastic about putting these principles into practice in her own home, she was a hypocrite, but not necessarily an active traitor…. the Serena of the TV series was actively complicit in people being murdered, tortured and abused.

    The second change they made to Serena… in the book it is implied that she was not sincerely religious and was just a huckster using televangelism as a ticket to fame and fortune. She doesn’t show any guilt that The Fundies have put some of her professed principles into practice and is just annoyed that all her wealth and social status has been taken away. She never makes any effort to help anyone unless it benefits her… the Serena of the series is sincerely religious, and was motivated to do all these terrible things out of a misguided sense of idealism. She also didn’t fully understand what the consequences would be and once she finds out she does feel some measure of genuine guilt, as well as doubt… Yvonne Strahovski is trying very hard in conveying Serena’s remorse too.

    So yeah, the TV-Serena is in some ways better and some ways worse than novel-Serena, and I agree… at this stage, given all she’s done, probably the only way she could satisfactorily redeem herself is to perform some act of resistance that involves sacrificing her own life.

    Also agree that Bradley Whitford is probably the most interesting thing going on here… both because of the unpredictable weirdness of the character, and the tasty ham n’ cheese of Whitfords performance.

    Also, nice literary allusion with Serena’s Mum being named Pamela… “Pam” is Serena’s real name in the novel, “Serena Joy” was just a stage-name/nickname.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.