Tell Me Lies: Season 3 Episode 4 – Recap and Review

There is a spectrum of how men can be, and while Stephen has shown himself to be the worst there is, does that make the others on Tell Me Lies that much better?

ByAmari Allah Hours Posted on

Spoiler Alert: This summary and review contains spoilers.

Additionally, some images and text may include affiliate links, meaning we may earn a commission or receive products if you make a purchase.

Episode 4 “Fix Me Up, Girl” Recap and Details

  • Director(s): Tyne Rafaeli
  • Writer(s): Liz Elverenli
  • Public Release Date (Hulu): January 20, 2026
  • Check out more of our “Tell Me Lies” coverage.

Word Of Mouth: Diana, Pippa, Molly, Evan, Stephen, Bree, Lucy, Caitie

Diana is pregnant, with Stephen’s baby, and originally, only Molly knew. However, to seemingly bond with Evan, initiate conversation after sex, she tells him Diana’s business. This leads him to tell Stephen, who, being that he is an ass, openly talks and yells about it, tells Pippa, and things just snowball. As you can imagine, Diana didn’t want this. Bad enough she has to wait a week to have an abortion, but now everyone knows, including Stephen, who wants to talk about her potentially not having an abortion?

It’s utter hell, but she isn’t alone. Caitie wants to reopen her case against Chris, drag Lucy in, but she doesn’t want any part of it. So, be it Caitie or a friend of hers, someone starts a Facebook group to expose Chris, adds Bree, and now Pippa finds herself in the worst situation possible. Her co-opted rape is becoming such a thing that she may have to stick up for Lucy and expose herself, and on top of that, her unofficial girlfriend is pregnant with a demon spawn.

Oh, and of course, Diana finds herself being asked what to do by Lucy. This is getting too big. Stephen has evidence to destroy her, and despite their history, Diana tries to help. But Stephen is already breathing down her neck, maybe having some desire to tell her dad she got pregnant, so while joining forces could potentially do something, it seems Diana would rather Lucy deal with the consequences of her actions – rightfully so.

The Unexpected Angel On Her Shoulder: Alex, Max, Lucy

Despite Alex pushing the idea that he didn’t want a relationship, to date, potentially not evolve to more than a sex buddy, he invites Lucy out to have a drink. It’s a weird scenario for Lucy. Being asked to meet up and it not be a date, not knowing what to wear, and Alex pokes fun at her about this. However, upon learning that Max, one of Lucy’s exes, is at the same bar, and she didn’t treat him well, Alex pushes her to apologize.

In a way, Alex does the opposite of what Stephen did. He doesn’t push Lucy to be at her worst but actually better. Now, granted, after Lucy apologizes, make Max look good on his date, she does have sex with Alex in his car, saying “I’m sorry” all the way through. So, call this all a twisted positive reinforcement.

How Did Bree and Evan Get Back Together?: Evan, Bree, Oliver, Wrigley, Stephen, Lydia, Lucy

It was never clear why Bree would get back with Evan. In this episode alone, he showed his behind by how Molly talked about getting on birth control, and the side effects, and his only focus was not having to wear a condom – potentially. How he handled the Diana situation, even willingly siding with Stephen, which will forever be a red flag, didn’t daunt him.

Yet, after Oliver broke Bree down and made her cry, and what she heard about Chris, Evan doesn’t seem that bad. Mind you, it is clear something with him, and Molly is going on besides something casual, but I guess hearing in the last episode he’d drop Molly like a bad habit for her was appealing?

I mean, it got them, albeit 6 years later, down the aisle, dancing at a reception, but it seems there are more secrets with this group than we knew. As shown, Wrigley and Bree have good chemistry, Bree notes she has regrets to Lucy and something is off. You’d think it was Stephen trying to ruin the wedding, but no one is thinking about him. Honestly, both Lucy and Bree make it clear he peaked in college and is just a sad and pathetic man. Even Lydia is starting to realize this, and that Stephen isn’t worth using to get back at Lucy.

But, you know, Stephen, he can’t take being knocked down and not look for a low blow to buy him some time to make a comeback. So, with realizing Wrigley and Bree keep having moments during the reception, and Wrigley leaving his phone exposed for snooping, Stephen learns they might have been a thing. Thus giving satan some new ammunition to cause chaos.

New Characters in Episode 4

Caitie (Taia Sophia)

  • Character Summary: Caitie is one of Chris’ original victims, in terms of date-rape, followed by Pippa, whose case against him got dismissed due to lack of evidence. But, with rumors getting around about Lucy having similar dealings with Chris, she hoped they could support each other in stopping him, but Lucy rejected this because she told a lie.

Review and Commentary

Highlights

Alex Being An Unexpected Good Influence [82/100]

Talk about circumventing expectations. Alex, appearing indifferent, above it all, and a drug dealer, never mind him liking dirty talk, which has Lucy degrade herself a bit, didn’t present the idea he’d want her to better herself. It’s weird, but I like it.

Take note, when not dating Stephen, Lucy can hook a decent guy. Leo, Max, and Alex, now, to a point, are decent dudes. Do they have dark sides to them? Yes. But, they’re in that range of, might play too much, get a little drunk, but aren’t going to blackmail you. But what gives Alex an edge to the point of being a highlight is that Lucy told him about Max and how sordid that relationship went, and seemingly, not to mess with her, but perhaps to heal her, he pushed her to apologize.

Now, I know that sounds weird, him wanting to heal her, but I don’t think it is lost on him that, as hot as the sex is, he is still a psychology major, never mind a grad student. Lucy has issues, and while I don’t think Alex is trying to be her unethical therapist, I also don’t believe he can just take advantage of someone who is undeniably vulnerable. After all, if he was that bad, I don’t think Bree would have encouraged Lucy to get with him.

Wrigley and Bree Had A Thing? [83/100]

Speaking of Bree, can we talk about this unspoken thing that seemingly happened between her and Wrigley? The season has been hinting that there was something there, but we can’t play down Wrigley has golden retriever energy, and Bree is like a chill puppy who just wants to hang out on your lap. It’s why, even at their version of being the worst, they are still very lovable.

I mean, maybe not the best example, but look at Pippa and Diana. Despite their history with Wrigley, they both adore that man. Yes, he was, maybe still is, a whore, but of the men in their life, he is strangely one of the good ones.

So, with that in mind, this leads to another odd crook in the road regarding how in the world did Bree end up with Evan? Unless Evan took a page out of Stephen’s book to snag Bree.

Evan Showing You Don’t Have To Be As Bad As Stephen To Still Be Trash [84/100]

Because Stephen is Lucifer’s spawn, as Bree made it seem regarding Chris, it can make every other guy seem good in comparison, even Evan. However, while I forget, but certainly don’t forgive him for cheating, this episode was a reminder of why he hasn’t had a good relationship since Bree – he’s quiet, and that just hides how much of an ass he is.

Telling Diana’s business to Stephen of all people, who he knows is dangerous, was a butt-head move. Him being completely oblivious to what Molly is doing, trying to connect with him, have small talk, hang out outside of having sex – it makes him an ass. Now, yes, there was an off-screen agreement seemingly made that they would just be having sex. However, Evan isn’t inexperienced. He is willingly ignorant.

For in my mind, Molly talking about Diana wasn’t just a means of trying to build a connection, but also a trust exercise. Evan already failed the pre-test by not listening to her about the side effects of birth control on her, and her worries, and just thinking that now he could hit it raw. So with this Diana thing, it was a chance to see if Evan had evolved, could be a good partner, and surely by the end of the episode, when Diana was ready to go off on her, she got her answer.

But really, the thing about Evan that makes me most upset is how much he represents men’s complicated alliances to even the worst of their fellow men. For truly, anyone who doesn’t take a step back when in agreement with Stephen and doesn’t question themselves, while they may not be as dangerous as him, it may only be because they don’t have the audacity and belief they could get away with what he does.

Why Pippa and Diana Finding Each Other Is So Important [87/100]

Pippa and Diana finding each other matters beyond the attraction and understanding between them, because their relationship also offers something neither of them has consistently been allowed: safety. Not just emotional safety, but the safety to be curious, unsure, and unpolished in ways that Bree and Lucy are repeatedly afforded.

When you look at Lucy and Bree, it’s clear that despite everything they endure (toxic relationships, manipulation, exploitation), they are still allowed to exist within girlhood. They are permitted to be naïve, vulnerable, messy, and to make mistakes without those mistakes permanently defining them. Their youth is acknowledged, even when it’s being preyed upon. Men protect them, pursue them, and in some cases, even if it is Stephen, fall on swords for them. Lucy benefits from Stephen taking the blame for the Drew letter, from Leo physically defending her, and from having multiple romantic “options.” Bree, too, is framed as young and soft — her messiness contextualized by her age, her background, and her perceived innocence.

Pippa and Diana do not receive that same grace.

Diana, from the moment we meet her, is positioned as composed, confident, and older-than-her-years. She is treated like a queen bee, admired, respected, and deferred to, but never truly allowed to be off. There is no sustained stretch where she gets to be naïve, vulnerable, or messy without consequence. When she falters, she is exposed rather than protected. Evan exposes her. Wrigley barely speaks up. Others watch as she is dragged through the mud, as though she should have known better, as though her age and competence disqualify her from grace.

The same is true for Pippa, perhaps even more brutally so. She is still paying the price for Wrigley’s sports career ending, still clawing her way back from being treated as a social pariah. She is blamed, isolated, and forced into a narrative where her worth is tied to sacrifice and endurance. Where Bree and Lucy stumble and are caught, Pippa stumbles and is punished. She is never allowed to be naïve, and when she is, the consequences are devastating.

This is where the difference becomes stark: Bree and Lucy get to transition. They get the liminal space Alex talked about in the last episode, the awkward, messy in-between of youth and adulthood. Pippa and Diana do not. They are treated as women to be looked up to, measured, and disciplined. They are expected to know better, to do better, and to carry themselves accordingly, even though they are around the same age as the girls being protected around them.

That’s why moments like Lucy going to Diana for advice don’t read as woman-to-woman exchanges. They feel like a teenager confiding in a cool older cousin. The power dynamic is already assumed. Diana is positioned as someone who should have answers, not someone still figuring things out herself.

Bree and Lucy, meanwhile, exist in a paradox where they are both infantilized and sexualized. Lucy’s vulnerability, her willingness to please, and her tendency to tolerate toxicity become points of fascination and desire. Bree’s shyness, sweetness, and insecurity are pedestalized. Their discomfort is softened, their mistakes framed as growing pains rather than moral failings.

Pippa and Diana are never afforded that framing. They cannot be young without risk. They cannot be unsure without repercussions.

Which is why Pippa and Diana exploring queerness with each other is such a profound shift. In finding each other, they step into a space where they are not required to be responsible, composed, or exemplary. They get a version of intimacy where curiosity isn’t punished, and vulnerability isn’t weaponized. For once, they are not the standard others measure themselves against. They are just two people figuring something out together.

That freedom, however brief or fragile, is something Bree and Lucy have always had access to.

Pippa and Diana had to find it in each other.

On The Fence

Oliver’s Reality Check [74/100]

I am of the belief that part of the goal for season 3 is to show the spectrum of men there are and to paint the picture that there is no perfect guy. While Evan and Stephen are terrible men, they are terrible in different ways, as is Oliver. He can be charming, make you feel seen, wanted, and mature, but he can also make you feel small, unworthy, and pick you apart like a child with a dandelion before blowing you away till only your core is left.

But, as much as I enjoy Tell Me Lies showing all the different ways trash men look and act, I still feel like Oliver has overstayed his welcome. There is no future for this character. Bree marries Evan, so Oliver is ultimately going to be a footnote. So, with his impact already felt, why is he still here?

The Chris Is A Rapist Storyline [73/100]

I get a character can’t just accuse someone of one of the most heinous crimes and move on like it is nothing. However, Chris was not that notable a character; I’m not even 100% sure if we’ve seen or met Caitie before this episode, and this all feels terribly mishandled to become a storyline. Like putting Stephen in the middle of a conversation about how men can feel about when their child is being aborted, having Lucy steal Pippa’s story, and watching this play out feels so icky.

And I get it, one of the things that Tell Me Lies likes to lean into is the uncomfortable. However, it is one thing to lean in and execute storylines well. It is another when it can feel like you are there for the drama, and how the storyline plays out is secondary. Which, to me, is how things are often done on this show.

Overall

Our Overall Rating [80/100]

Wrigley, Diana, and Pippa are what keep me watching long-term. I’ve gotten my fill with Stephen, Evan feels like he skirts on not being as bad as Stephen to get away with still being trash, and as much as I enjoy Bree, she broke Wrigley’s heart. Oh, and as for Lucy? She might be the lead but just as much as Evan isn’t as bad as Oliver, but they are part of the same spectrum, Lucy may not be the worst thing about the show, but her value can seem as limited as Stephen’s.

What To Check Out Next

Visit our main TV shows page! There you’ll find other shows we’ve covered or look below for more of our coverage for this series:

TV Shows We’re Covering This Season

Images used for editorial and commentary purposes. All rights remain with their respective copyright holders.

Listed Under Categories:
Related Tags: , , , , ,

Amari is the founder and head writer of Wherever-I-Look.com and has been reviewing media since 2010. He approaches each production with hope, rooting for every story to succeed, and believes criticism should come from unmet potential, while praise is reserved for work that meets or exceeds expectations.