Home Movies Fantasy Island (2020) – Review/ Summary (with Spoilers)

Fantasy Island (2020) – Review/ Summary (with Spoilers)

by Amari

“Fantasy Island” may surprise you with how it tries to be more than a horror movie and address the trauma of the guests on the island.

Community Rating: 60.2% (3)


Director(s)Jeff Wadlow
Screenplay ByJillian Jacobs, Christopher Roach, Jeff Wadlow
Date Released (Theatrical)2/14/2020
Genre(s)Fantasy, Horror, Adventure
Duration1 Hour, 50 Minutes
Noted Cast
Mr. RoarkeMichael Pena
JuliaParisa Fitz-Henley
GwenMaggie Q
MelanieLucy Hale
PatrickAustin Stowell
BraxJimmy O. Yang
JDRyan Hansen
AllenRobbie Jones
SloanePortia Doubleday
NickEvan Evagora

This content contains pertinent spoilers.

Plot Summary/ Review (Ending Spoilers & Sequel Potential on the 2nd Page)

At Fantasy Island, Mr. Roarke, alongside his assistant Julia, help their guests, Gwen, Melanie, Patrick, Brax, and JD get acclimated to their inclusive resort. One which allows each person to live out a fantasy. For Gwen, it is to roll back the clock and accept the proposal from a man named Allen. Melanie? Oh, she wants to torture her 8th-grade bully, Sloane, and ruin her life. Patrick? Well, he wants to experience what it is like to be a soldier, like his dad was, and as for Brax and JD? They just want to live the high life.

But, as Mr. Roarke makes clear, while the island does bestow the fantasy people want, how it ultimately plays out may not be what is expected. And for the guest, they learn why the saying, “Be careful what you wish for” is tried and true.

Question(s) Left Unanswered

  1. What were the fantasies of all the members of Mr. Roarke’s staff?
  2. Do dreams or those who died on the island power it?


There Is A Surprising Emotional Element

When it comes to Patrick and Gwen’s fantasies, which deal with the loss of a loved one, and what could have been, despite this primarily being a horror movie, you may find yourself in your feelings a bit. For with Gwen experiencing the life she could have had with Allen, Q presents us with a romantic drama about a woman who questions what she deserves. Then with Patrick, who wanted to be a soldier, his encounter with his father, days before his untimely death, makes it so those two feel like they are in their own film separate from “Fantasy Island.”

Which isn’t to say they don’t eventually come together and meld with the other storylines, but while the other fantasies are shallow, or borderline ridiculous at times, these two have heart.

The Occasional Funny Moments/ Jump Scares

Between JD and Brax, and the occasional smart remark from Melanie, there are a handful of comical one-liners. Not necessary enough to say this movie is funny, but it knows how to mix things up so that if you aren’t enjoying one person’s fantasy, you can at least say this person’s or that person gave you what you needed. Then, in terms of scares, while only 3 jump scares got me, depending on how skittish you might be, there is the potential for you to get the fright you are looking for on a consistent basis.

On The Fence

How Everyone’s Story Ties Together

The ending, spoken on page 2, makes sense but also unravels some of the good things you’d say about “Fantasy Island” since it is cliché. Much less, the person who is at the center of the twist gets erratic to the point you may laugh or roll your eyes – depending on your sense of humor.


Would Watch Again? – One and Done

Rating: Positive (Worth Seeing)

While by no means the best horror film in recent memory, what makes this worth seeing is that it continues to push Blumhouse as a brand that wants to go beyond the usual expectations when it comes to thrillers/horrors. And with “Fantasy Island,” while it ultimately gives in to the negative expectations that horror movies inspire, with how it handles Gwen and Patrick’s characters, you are reminded this is the same company behind “Get Out” as well as “Sharp Objects.”

So if you want a one and done horror movie to see, just for fun, you might want to check out “Fantasy Island.”

What Would Your Rating Be?

Negative Mixed Positive

[td_block_12 custom_title=”Other Movies & Shorts” td_ajax_filter_type=”” ajax_pagination=”next_prev” limit=”1″ category_id=”34″ sort=”random_posts” custom_url=”https://wherever-i-look.com/media/movie-master-list”]

Fantasy Island Ending Spoilers

What we learn is that, in the end, everyone was experiencing a micro-fantasy which was under Melanie’s fantasy. One which dealt with revenge. She wanted revenge on Sloane for bullying her in middle school and high school to the point of needing therapy. And then for the rest? She wanted to make them suffer for taking away Nick from her.

Now, who is Nick? Some guy she had one date with that was JD and Brax’s roommate, who died in a fire caused by Gwen, and despite being a cop, Patrick didn’t rescue. And because of her fantasy JD dies, and also Patrick who, as his father did, uses his body to dispel the damage that could be done by a grenade. One that Melanie throws, after Sloane creates a fantasy of Melanie and the charred up Nick getting to be together, which leads to her being drowned. But, to truly show how close Brax and JD were, he gives himself over to the island to revive his brother who, somehow, gets to leave despite us clearly seeing him die.

But, considering how limited the information is on what powers the island, and if the fantasy can truly extend beyond space, time, and the island itself, JD’s rebirth might end once beyond the realm of the island. Making it so the only thing we know for sure is Gwen and Sloane left without magic being involved. Also, Mr. Roarke, who sacrificed his wife, Julia, to keep them alive, says they are likely not to remember most of what happened beyond the more euphoric moments.

Is A Sequel Possible?

There is honestly nothing stopping this from having a sequel, but one isn’t built in. Plus, one would assume, in a sequel, they’d have to avoid repeating what we saw in having a bunch of people who seem to be strangers be connected by someone unexpected and not named until it is convenient.

[td_block_12 custom_title=”Other Movies & Shorts” td_ajax_filter_type=”” ajax_pagination=”next_prev” limit=”1″ category_id=”34″ sort=”random_posts” custom_url=”https://wherever-i-look.com/category/movies”]

What Would Your Rating Be?

Negative Mixed Positive

Negative  (33%) Mixed  (0%) Positive  (67%)

1 comment

Mimi Justus February 24, 2020 - 12:26 AM

I LOVED this film, it paid just enough homage to the original to be respected, enough suspense to keep me paying attention yet updated enough to make it relevant.


Questions, Comments or Difference of Opinion?

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.