Reasonable Doubt: Season 3 Episode 1 – Recap and Review
Reasonable Doubt does what few shows can in return from break without stumbling.
Spoiler Alert: This summary and review contains spoilers.
Additionally, some images and text may include affiliate links, meaning we may earn a commission or receive products if you make a purchase.
Episode 1 “Feeling’ It” Details
- Available On: Hulu
- Public Release Date: September 18, 2025
- Director(s): Anton Cropper
- Writer(s): Jordan Crawford, Raamla Mohamed
- Check out our page for this series, featuring more recaps, reviews, and articles.
Episode 1 “Feeling’ It” Storylines/ Recap
Ongoing Lawsuit: Jax, Toni, Lewis
It has been almost a year since Toni filed her lawsuit, and it hasn’t really gotten anywhere. Jax’s need to win has dragged this out, involved her going through three attorneys, and has only caused Toni to raise the wall to get her to drop this. By the time the episode ends, she presents the offer of 1.5 million, with the removal of the non-disparagement and confidentiality clause, or getting to have a night with Lewis.
As for a night with Lewis doing what? That it isn’t clear, since he had that conversation with her off-screen, but who knows if Toni would honor such an agreement, never mind Jax agreeing to it.
Ambitious, But Is He Trustworthy?: Jax, Bill
At work, Jax isn’t the hotshot she usually is. She is a criminal defense attorney, and with most clients copping plea deals, she isn’t getting billable hours from being at trial, and to be frank, she is also getting bored. Bill (Joseph Sikora), on the other hand, who wants to become an equity partner, is bringing in notable money. However, with only 6 years at the firm, Jax blocks him from becoming an equity partner, so he tries to meet with her and gain her trust.
Which he does, to a point, hence her inviting him to help with this season’s case.
The Case Of The Season: Jax, Wendy, Ozzie
Ozzie Edwards (Kyle Bary) rose to fame playing Caleb Kensington on My Cousins and Them, for which he won multiple Emmy awards. Now 24, there is an effort made by his team (his parents and agent) to have him transition to more serious roles, even romantic ones, but a problem his parents see is that he is very much in love with his White stylist, Wendy (Rumer Willis). She is older, by no means passing for any ethnicity other than White, and Ozzie is at odds with his family and team regarding her.
But when he does choose her over his family, a fight ensues when she doesn’t seem to appreciate the weight of his decision. Next thing we know, she is missing, her personal items found near a freeway, and Jax is called in to be his defense, thus leading her to get not only those billable hours, but also the challenge she so desperately needs.
Other Noteworthy Information
- Corey is still around and was one of the first people Ozzie called regarding his case, but Jax ends up getting the case, and later invites Bill to join
- Ozzie’s team is his mom, Rosie (April Parker Jones), dad, Sal (Keith Arthur Bolden), and agent Monica Wilson (Brandee Evans).
- Dr. Brandy and Corey are still together
- Lewis has hired a new Black person, a coder who knows C++ and Python named Sam (Martin Jakes Jr.), whom he hopes to make friends with
Review and Commentary
Highlights
Bill Being A Wild Card [82/100]
While Corey is some form of an ally and cool with Jax, at her firm, it continues to appear that only her subordinates have her back. As for her fellow lawyers? She is given respect due to her name being on the building, but actually liking her is a whole other thing, and you could submit that many would stab her in the back if they could get away with it.
So with Bill being ambitious, there is a need to ask, especially with the conversation he had prior to talking to Jax, is he friend or foe? He did take her out to lunch, showed he had a Black wife, and made it seem he isn’t trying to hide his endgame, but does that make him trustworthy? Never mind, if he is poised to sabotage Jax, how could he and would it only be because she blocked him from becoming an equity partner, or would he be a pawn in a much bigger game?
Ozzie’s Case [83/100]
The best thing about Ozzie’s case is that he does live up to the title of the show, since there is reasonable doubt. The ones in the past, there were reasons to believe they did it, but with Ozzie, there is this desire to hope he is innocent, which helps immensely. Plus, add in his parents being on his payroll, his agent being a recognizable actress, and you’ve got a lot of people who could have done something.
Now, the episode does end with him showing scratch marks on his chest, but who knows if that was from Wendy, never mind if he killed her after their fight.
Probably The Best Season Opener In A While [85/100]
When it comes to most shows we watch, there is this feeling that things have to pick up once a new season starts, and honestly, it can be a bit rough. Reasonable Doubt doesn’t give that feeling. Yes, for it feels formulaic by starting with a mystery and then jumping back in time? Yes. But, things pick up quickly enough, it doesn’t overwhelm us with new faces, and quickly establishes what is the case of the season, and makes it compelling.
Ultimately, presenting the idea that those behind the show know what works, and while they are still looking to do things better to hold onto its audience, they also know them well enough to start things off on the right foot.
On The Fence
The Toni Drama [74/100]
I think the issue for us regarding Toni is that, when it comes to Jax’s personal life, we want better storylines. Heck, the storylines that don’t deal with her job in general. We partly see that through the focus on Lewis and him hiring a new programmer, and there is the need to question what’s going on with all of Jax’s friends after the events of the last season.
So one can only hope this Toni drama gets swept under the rug and the show promptly moves on thereafter.
Overall
Our Overall Rating [81/100]
Reasonable Doubt reminds viewers why it is one of Hulu’s rare Black shows to survive beyond 1 season. Whether it is the intrigue in the season’s case, the question of whether new character Bill is friend or foe, or just the type of confidence that feels like it knows what works, but also being humble enough to know it still has to work to keep fans’ attention, it provides everything you could want.
Well, outside of moving on from the Toni storyline.
What To Check Out Next
Visit our main page TV Shows we’ve covered.
-
Reasonable Doubt: Season 3 Episode 2 – Recap and Review
As Ozzie’s case begins to pick up, it is hard to say if he is playing a role or showing his real face.
-
Reasonable Doubt: Season 2 – Review
Season 2 shows progress from the growing pains of season 1, but still seems a bit bloated and like it undertilizes its potential.
-
Reasonable Doubt: Season 2 Episode 10 “Encore” – Recap and Review
Season 2 ends on a less shocking note than season 1, but also a bit more emotional than season 1 as well.
