Star: Season 3/ Episode 5 “Someday We’ll All Be Free” – Recap/ Review (with Spoilers)

The girls talking to one another.
53.02% (1)

As Carlotta has a breakdown, revealing her dark past, Miss Bruce FINALLY get some development.


Network
Fox
Director(s) Janice Cooke
Writer(s) Leo Richardson, Jordan E. Cooper
Air Date 10/31/2018

Images and text in this post may contain affiliate links which, if a purchase is made from those sites, I may earn money or products from the company. Most affiliate links contain an upward facing, superscript, arrow.

Powerplay: Megan, Noah, Maurice, Cassie

With Megan finding things in the contract necessary to play Maurice, so comes the question of who is using who? Is Noah using Megan so that he can get back at Maurice for trying to make him an indentured servant at Karma or is this Megan getting more digs at Maurice? It’s hard to say but what is clear is that Megan and Noah have grown close over these investigations and now have a thing going on. Making Maurice’s attempts to recover his former life seem more and more distant.

Yet, with no ability to take out the anger he has on Noah, he decides to try to direct it at revenge against Carlotta. Problem is, with Cassie seeing what Carlotta is going for as an opening for their relationship to heal, she doesn’t want Maurice standing in the way of that. She even pulls a gun on him. Unfortunately for her though, Maurice calls her bluff and keeps it stepping. Be it because he knows she won’t shoot him in the middle of a club or because he has no time for her mess.

Commentary

Noah and Megan about to kiss.

All I’m saying is, he could just go back to Megan Goode’s character. Yeah, she skims and is a bit shady but clearly his ex-wife doesn’t want anything from him. They don’t have kids together, just a past which she has no real desire in revisiting. Which you can’t blame her for. In talking with Noah, she talks about how she uprooted her life, started over, and worked her way into a prominent position. So why would she go back to the man who was the catalyst for this? Maybe, because of how they ended things, Megan did more than get a new haircut but started a whole new life. Even got this young thing interested and feeling like everything is coming up Megan.

But, will the same be said for Cassie? With her ex still married and now her pulling a gun on Maurice, will she get to solidify her new start? Because I’m sure Maurice isn’t going to take a gun being pulled on him as just another day working with Cassie. He may start working on a plan to use her past against her so that she no longer has a part of Karma. Which, really, can you blame him?

I Was A Fool To Trust You: Olivia, Alex, Derek, Nina, Simone, Mateo, Star

Olivia goes full crazy, even seems like she wanted to reenact the movie Misery by bringing Alex to her home, a trailer somewhere, and maybe keep her trapped. However, between Star not liking this girl, and her threatening her child, she works with Derek to take her down. Leading to, of course, that sex tape leaking in retaliation.

Speaking of leaking information, Simone speaks to Nina, in confidence, about Carlotta’s situation and she tells Mateo. Pushing the idea, despite their past, Simone is simply her artist – not her friend. Which, of course, makes Simone feel a certain kind of way since Simone doesn’t get close to that many people. Most of the time she doesn’t show that sweet side of a girl who is barely 18, she shows that rough neck who Star partially raised. So, she keeps in mind what Nina did to her.

Yet, what choice did Nina have? Mateo is gambling with company money and seemingly has a long established gambling problem. So with Carlotta away, it means she needed Mateo to step his game up because she can’t do everything on her own. She may handle the money but he is the face and she isn’t trying to pick up that task.

Commentary

Olivia before being caught by cops.

Alex deserves such a side eye. Your parents are famous, alongside rich, you are famous, and are building your own wealth, so did it never come to mind to do a background check? Was there never a fear, when growing up, of being used because of your fame, kidnapped, none of that? Granted, I wouldn’t see someone like Olivia as someone who is crazy and to be worried about but that’s only because there is a certain, crackhead, look that is the sole type Black people double take on. It usually isn’t an Olivia type. But, there were so many red flags there.

Then again, let’s not forget her parents were dysfunctional, she has been riding with Star and Simone who are just as dysfunctional, just without money, so maybe Olivia seemed normal to Alex? Just another nutcase entering her life who she just has to learn how to adapt to their unique brand of crazy? Hence why she was making excuses for her when the cops came. Rather than flipping out as Star was.

Bringing us to this Nina and Simone situation. I was expecting an affair but I guess Nina keeps her belt tighter than Mateo. Heck, taking note they just partied together and may have slept together in a non-sexual way, maybe she’d be Simone’s next maternal figure. If not like an older sister. But I guess that isn’t going to happen since Simone isn’t quick to forgive. She mid-key petty and even with Star, their relationship healing came from Star pushing it and this pending baby. If Star didn’t put that effort in, they’d still be beefing. Well, Star pushing it and Ms. Carlotta too.

You’ve Been Strong On Your Own Too Long: Carlotta, Cassie, Miss Bruce, Bobby, Cotton

Carlotta thanking the ghost of Jahil.
Carlotta: Thank you

To put it simply, Carlotta may have had a nervous breakdown and based on what Cassie has said, this might not have been the first time. As Cassie has spoken on before, while their mom was hustling, Carlotta took care of the house in her stead. She was running things and raising Cassie! But, one thing Cassie didn’t know is that this idea their parents loved Carlotta more was false. For one, Christine was just able to rely on Carlotta, so that made her useful. As for their father, well, he seemingly was raping Carlotta and making her take on all of what was expected of her mother.

Something Carlotta notes she took just to protect Cassie. Adding a multitude of layers to her story from why she is so hurt Cassie is messing with her like this to why she took to Simone the way she did – beyond Mary and skin color. Heck, even why she puts up with Star. It’s because, at one time, she either identified with both or saw them as she saw herself and Cassie. But, to throw some more fire into the mix, Carlotta reveals to Cotton what Cassie did.

And while Carlotta works through her past, so does Miss Bruce. It’s just for them, they have Bobby by their side rather than them being like Carlotta and just struggling on their own. For trying to help out Carlotta, as usual, while she is struggling, isn’t an easy job. Carlotta wears many hats and always got a hustle going and why she got certain ways about her, she can’t be denied. However, Miss Bruce? As seen by how one promoter treats them, as professional as they try to be, they still get undermined, underestimated, and there is some attempt to other them.

Leading them to go back to when they first got a taste of that treatment – the church. Specifically, their father’s church and Bobby comes along for the ride. Leading to Miss Bruce having a Shug Avery moment, just without a daddy to embrace them despite their past. But, as a stand-in maybe, they do get to have a moment with Bobby. One person who is just strictly their friend, and hopefully can become something more.

Commentary

Bobby and Miss Bruce standing across from one another.

One thing that has kept Star as something I’ve stuck with, over three seasons, is that as annoying as it can get with this Olivia thing, even Cassie early on, the show knows how to clean itself up. Also, I’d like to believe when it sees something isn’t working, it decides it is time to kill off some characters. Hunter and his momma? Took a while, but now they are out and shouldn’t be seen again. Same thing with the Muslim girl. It would have been cool to have her but she was a legit threat to Alex and Derek since she was everything he was looking for. Even gave him one of his first accident boners. So, she disappeared. Wasn’t much left for Angel so he was written off, and the same might be done with Olivia now.

And while the show sometimes replaces those characters with ones which make you roll your eyes, you have to admire the show’s efforts to stay fresh. It takes note of who is the core, who fans love, like Miss Bruce and Ms. Ruby, and decide to, as they introduce characters like Bobby, raise those people up. Maybe even integrate the new folk in their lives or make them a source of conflict.

Now, speaking to the topic at hand, what more can be said really? The writers have crafter with Carlotta a means for you to understand why Cassie killing who she loves hurts so deeply. For she sacrificed so much for that woman that for her to take the one thing that brought her happiness. The person who loved her as hard as she loved them, it’s devastating.

Also, it adds layers to the connection Carlotta has to Mary’s kids since their story is so close to hers. Star, in many ways, can be seen as an unrefined Carlotta. Simone, in other ways, can be seen as Carlotta at her weakest or maybe Cassie, in terms of someone she has to protect. Hence her going overtime for not just redemption but to try to save them from the mistakes she and Cassie made.

Though, the biggest thing I’m happy about this episode is Miss Bruce FINALLY being more than a quip here and Carlotta’s sidekick. We finally got to learn their past, which was long overdue after Derek’s offhand comment in season 2. Plus, Miss Bruce may get a man? Not to forget, they are finally out of the salon, out in the world, and bossing up? Legally at that?

Now, this doesn’t come with some caveats of course, since it seems Cotton has passed the “What LGBT people go through” baton. Thus making her feel kind of secondary. But, this isn’t Pose so I guess we should appreciate what we get. Especially on network TV. With that said, her and Bobby better end up together and have a sex scene. I’m tired of it just being 25 and under who are the only gay folk who seemingly got a sex life. We got diversity in skin tone, now even sexuality. So let’s work on age, body types, and things like that now.

Collected Quote(s) & .Gifs

Can’t get rid of no storm with thunder on your back.
— Miss Bruce

Sober don’t mean selfish.
—Miss Bruce

Highlights

  1. Miss Bruce getting some long needed development.
  2. Carlotta’s connection to Star and Simone deepening
  3. The possibility of never seeing Olivia again.
  4. Us learning Mateo has a gambling problem.

On The Fence

  1. Carlotta talking about heading to Jamaica to relax, get some therapy, and process some things. Um, I’m cool with Miss Bruce taking up your screen time but what’s going on here?


Follow Wherever I Look on Twitter, Like us on Facebook and Subscribe to the YouTube Channel.


Check Out Other TV Recaps


Season/ EpisodeSynopsis

Season 3/ Episode 6 “Ante Up”

Love and distrust are in the air and with it being Star, you know no one is having an easy time dealing with their feelings.

Director(s) John Krokidas
Writer(s) Randy Huggins, Rebecca Boss, Chris Masi
Air Date 11/7/2018
Introduced This Episode
Maria Gabrielle Walsh

Featuring: Miss Bruce, Maria, Derek, Alex, Cotton, Cassie, Maurice, Xander, Simone, Nina, Jackson, Star, Megan, Noah

Season 3/ Episode 5 “Someday We’ll All Be Free”

As Carlotta has a breakdown, revealing her dark past, Miss Bruce FINALLY get some development.

Director(s) Janice Cooke
Writer(s) Leo Richardson, Jordan E. Cooper
Air Date 10/31/2018

Featuring: Megan, Noah, Maurice, Cassie, Olivia, Alex, Derek, Nina, Simone, Mateo, Star, Carlotta, Miss Bruce, Bobby, Cotton

Season 3/ Episode 4 “All Falls Down”

As Carlotta goes off the deep end, Noah takes a page from Star’s book and Olivia… well, let’s just say she becomes more annoying than Cassie.

Season 3/ Episode 3 “A Family Affair”

As Star and Noah worth through their daddy issues, Cassie and Carlotta’s beef reaches a boiling point. Also, Miss Bruce may get a man.

Season 3/ Episode 2 “Who’s The Daddy?”

As we finally learn who Star’s baby daddy is, most of the cast is trying to deal with their past so that it doesn’t impede the joy pending in their future.

Season 1/ Episode 1 "Pilot"

Season 1/ Episode 2 "The Devil You Know"

Season 1/ Episode 3 "Next of Kin"

Season 1/ Episode 4 "Code of Silence"

Season 1/ Episode 5 "New Voices"

Season 1/ Episode 6 "Infamous"

Season 1/ Episode 7 “Black Wherever I Go”

Season 1/ Episode 8 “Mama’s Boy”

Season 1/ Episode 9 “Alibi”

Season 1/ Episode 10 “Boy Trouble”

Season 1/ Episode 11 “Saving Face”

Season 1

Season 1/ Episode 12 “Showtime”

Season 2/ Episode 1 “The Winner Takes It All”

5 months have passed since Star: Season 1 ended and damn! Wait till you find out all that has happened since then.

Season 2/ Episode 2 “Insecure”

While Star understands the struggle and hustle, her peers are letting setbacks bring them down and get distracted.

Season 2/ Episode 3 “FUA… Good Night!”

As Alex begins breaking under pressure, the girls continue to push Ayanna’s buttons and leave Carlotta to clean up their mess.

Season 2/ Episode 4 “It Ain’t Over”

With Brody’s return comes the reminder of the effect of Mary’s death and we're also reminded people have lives outside of their work w/ Star.

Season 2/ Episode 5 “May The Best Manager Win”

We are introduced to the new name of the group, Take Three, and police brutality returns to focus for Star.

Season 2/ Episode 6 “Faking It”

As the pressure to get into the showcase rises, so does Derek with someone who isn’t Alex and Jahil with Ayanna.

Season 2/ Episode 7 “Ghetto Symphony”

Alex really begins to take center stage but best believe that Star isn’t going to let that last for too long.

Season 2/ Episode 8 “A House Divided”

Be it the recent or distant past, everyone’s seems to be thrown up in their face. Be it due to another's person or through reminders of recent failings.

Season 2/ Episode 9 “Climax”

Star leaves us with the kind of cliffhanger which seems like a desperate move for ratings vs. for the betterment of the story.

Season 2 (First Half)

The first half of Star Season 2 pushes us 5 months after the season 1 finale and it seems despite the major career step, everyone’s personal lives remain in disarray.

Season 2/ Episode 10 “Rise From The Ashes”

The show returns, the drama continues, but now there is a secret of what happened in the 10 days since the mid-season finale.

Season 2/ Episode 11 “Take It To Church”

The drama begins to rev up as old memories and characters begin haunting our leads, as well as possible new love interests.

Season 2/ Episode 12 “Dreamers”

Brody’s past comes to haunt him, as Star learns the truth about what happened the day her mother died. Alongside this, Simone finds a way to even things up with Angel.

Season 2/ Episode 13 “Forward (E)Motion”

Clearly, everyone at Midtown needs a few rounds of therapy. For between using sex and alcohol to cope, there is going to come a moment when someone doesn’t get to be so lucky.

Season 2/ Episode 14 “After The Set, It’s The Afterparty”

Many of the relationships end up in jeopardy as third parties try to get involved. But, at least with one new third party, it seems everyone’s career may be moving forward.

Season 2/ Episode 15 “Let The Good Times Roll”

Sexual assault, LGBT issues, alongside Ayanna making a triumphant return is featured. Alongside your usual relationship drama.

Season 2/ Episode 16 “Take It Or Leave It”

Things have been kind of holding together, but falling apart for awhile. But, as Alex’s star rises, and she begins to really leave Take Three behind, Star finds herself making some moves.

Season 2/ Episode 17 “Mrs. Rivera”

The characters of Star all go through so much this episode that even trying to figure out what may happen in the finale will depend if the writers will get their foot off our necks.

Season 2/ Episode 18 “Thirty Days To Famous”

It’s a new dawn, it’s a new day, it’s a new life for many on Star. But ain’t a single person feeling good about the cards given to them.

Season 3/ Episode 1 “Secrets & Lies”

3 months have passed, and we learn the results of the multiple cliffhangers of the last season. Most of which will make you roll your eyes.

Season 2 (Second Half)

The second half, of season 2, of Star seemingly is about cutting any and all fat so that season 3 can refocus on core characters.

How Would You Rate This?

Negative Mixed Positive

About Amari Sali 3332 Articles
New Jersey native Amari Sali takes the approach of more so being a media advisor than a critic to sort of fill in the gap left between casual fans of media and those who review productions for a living. Thus being open about bias while still giving enough insight, often with spoilers, to present whether something is worth seeing, buying, renting, streaming, or checking out at all.

Be the first to comment

Questions, Comments, or Opposing Opinion?

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.