Title Card - Lying and Stealing (2019)

Read our Editorial Guidelines regarding how posts are written and rated and our use of affiliate links.

Lying and Stealing is a quick film which may not leave a lasting impact but is a pleasant way to kill an hour and a half.

Director(s) Matt Aselton
Screenplay By Matt Aselton, Adam Nagata
Date Released 7/12/2019
Genre(s) Crime, Drama
Good If You Like
  • Following A Thief Trying To Clear Their Debt
  • A Decent Brotherhood Story
Isn’t For You If You Want A Female Lead Who Is Well Beyond A Love Interest
Noted Cast
Ivan Theo James
Elyse Emily Ratajkowski
Ray Ebon Moss-Bachrach
Lyman Wilkers Isiah Whitlock Jr.
Dimitri Fred Melamed

Images and text in this post may contain affiliate links which, if a purchase is made, we’ll earn money or products from the company. Affiliate links and external links include an upward facing, superscript, arrow.

Lying and Stealing Plot Summary & Review

Thanks to his father, Ivan has long worked with a man named Dimitri to clear his father’s debt. Something that his brother, Raymond, barely, if ever, helps with. But, with growing tired of stealing for Dimitri, Ivan tries to figure out when is he going to be done? It isn’t made clear how long her has been working, but with the items getting harder to get, and Dimitri dictating terms, it’s understandably frustrating. So, with the last few pieces set, Ivan pursues clearing his dad’s debt and moving on with his life.

That is, if a new woman in his life, Elyse, or an FBI agent, Lyman Wilkers, don’t end up bringing him down or getting him killed.



While taking note Ratajkowski isn’t necessarily stretching her abilities as an actress, you have to admit she plays the role of the charming girlfriend well. One who seems to have a mischievous side to her and while, as many of her characters, the writing is thin, she works with it. Not enough to say she could do so much more, but she had definitely found a niche she is comfortable in.

On The Fence

The Brotherhood Between Ivan and Ray

To a certain degree, you’d think between the issue of their father’s debt and Ray struggling a bit, there would be a more emotional, perhaps volatile at times, relationship between Ivan and Ray. Yeah, that doesn’t exist. Often, Ray doesn’t seem more than a light-hearted fellow with issues, never really dove into, that Ivan is obligated to help because he is his sibling. And with Ray either covering his tracks, or just not being much of a bother, Ivan rarely feels the need to talk to him, confront him, or flesh out their childhoods a bit more.

Agent Wilkers & Dimitri When Working With Ivan

Ivan did go to art school, and is clever, but there is something about him which makes you think the way James plays him vs. how Ivan is written doesn’t match up. Like James gave Ivan an edge and made him a low-budget action hero. One who didn’t get as many fight scenes, but was put in situations where he had to almost act like a spy and present enough charm to make people complacent. Which seemingly was at the expense of Agent Wilkers and Dimitri.

Now, don’t get me wrong, Dimitri does still present himself as a Greek thug, head of a small-time crime organization type. It’s just, between him and Agent Wilkers, something about those two seems more comical than formidable. Not to imply they are tripping all over themselves like they’re in Three Stooges film, but as serious as James makes their interactions seem, there is this weird disconnect. Like they aren’t all acting with the same expectations, in tone, for the movie.

Lying and Stealing Overall: Mixed (Divisive)

The reason Lying and Stealing is being labeled “Mixed” primarily is due from there just being something off about this film. Maybe it is due to James seeming like he isn’t on the same page as everyone else? Perhaps it is that, as much as you can see there should be a more complicated relationship between Ivan, Ray, and their father, that is graced over? Heck, maybe it is due to Elyse being your usual love interest, with minimum depth, or Dimitri and Agent Wilkers not really written, or performed, to have nuance.

To be honest, this is one of those films where if you overthink about it, it will quickly lead to your enjoyment descending. So take it easy, just enjoy Ivan stealing things and, usually, getting away with it, and you’ll have a good time.

Follow Wherever I Look on Twitter, Like us on Facebook and Subscribe to the YouTube Channel.

[ninja_tables id=”24271″]

Lying and Stealing Ending Explained & Commentary (with Spoilers)

Ending Explained

Between Agent Wilkers and Dimitri, it is clear Ivan is either going to end up in jail or dead. For while Dimitri seems more bark than bite, just because we don’t see him get his hands dirty, doesn’t mean he isn’t capable. After all, he has henchmen. So, working with Agent Wilkers, who feels he has hit a “Black Ceiling” and could use a big fish, Ivan plans his out. First, by recording all his conversations with Agent Wilkers, to make it so he can’t stab him in the back, then using Elyse and Ray, they take him somewhere he could either be negotiated with or killed.

In the long run, thanks to Ray having him OD on cocaine, he is killed. Thus, with a blackmail tape, and Dimitri dead, as well as his henchmen, of which there are only two, Ivan is free! Yet, because he loves stealing, money on the table of not, he continues to do so. Just, unlike before, he doesn’t do it solo but with Ray and Elyse assisting.

Is A Sequel Possible?

All things considered, yes. Ivan stole from a lot of people and while Dimitri is dead, the thief is not. Plus, as Agent Wilkers said, it wasn’t that hard to track down Ivan. Also, we don’t know who Dimitri’s buyers were and whether they could want more and find Ivan, if not one of the people he stole from may not hunt him down. For example, the one who he stole Hitler memorabilia from, between two dogs, and his military training, who is to say he wouldn’t hunt Ivan down for what’s his? Especially since, in the film, Ivan didn’t sell or give that to anyone so he likely still has it.

Follow Wherever I Look on Twitter, Like us on Facebook and Subscribe to the YouTube Channel.

[ninja_tables id=”24271″]

Ratajkowski - 80%
The Brotherhood Between Ivan and Ray - 75%
Agent Wilkers & Dimitri When Working With Ivan - 74%


User Rating: Be the first one !

Listed Under Categories: ,

Follow, Like and Subscribe

User Review
0 (0 votes)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.