The Watchful Eye: Season 1/ Episode 1 “Hen In The Fox House” – Recap/ Review

A con artist and their boyfriend try to rob the rich, but with having to play the long game, they seemingly will have to weather many secrets to get their prize.

Community Rating: 0.00% (0) - No Community Ratings Submitted (Add Yours Below)

Read our Editorial Guidelines regarding how posts are written and rated and our use of affiliate links.

Wallpaper at the Greybourne

A con artist and their boyfriend try to rob the rich, but with having to play the long game, they seemingly will have to weather many secrets to get their prize.

Aired (FreeForm) 1/30/2023
Director(s) Jeffrey Reiner
Writer(s) Julie Durk
Noted Characters
Elena Mariel Molino
Matthew Warren Christie
Tory Amy Acker
Jasper Henry Joseph Samiri
Scott Jon-Michael Ecker
Allie Emily Tennant
Elliot Lex Lumpkin
Mrs. Ivey Kelly Bishop
Bennet Grace Kaufman
Darcy Megan Best
Kim Clare Filipow
Alex Baraka Rahmani
Jocelyn Elyse Maloway
Ginny Aliyah Royale
Dick Christopher Redman


This content contains pertinent spoilers. Also, images and text in this post may contain affiliate links which, if a purchase is made from those sites, we may earn money or products from the company.

First Things First, You Got To Get Hired – Elena, Matthew, Tory, Jasper, Scott, Allie

Allie, a very wealthy woman, decided to commit suicide. The reason why is a mystery, as her suicide note didn’t get circulated. What is known, though, is that Matthew, her husband, inherited eight figures and has tried to secure a nanny for months, but his sister-in-law, Tory, has fired and ran off each and every one. However, Elena is different. While she doesn’t have much in the way of childcare experience, her background raising her brother pairs well with Matthew growing up in a trailer. So, while Tory protests, Elena is hired.

This is a boon for Elena, for on top of a salary and it being a live-in position, with her boyfriend Scott, she plans to prey upon the wealthy members of the Greybourne building to find out about this precious ruby that could set her and Scott for life. But, before she can secure that ruby, she has to secure the affection of Jasper, the kid she is supposed to watch, which, thankfully, is easy.

All These Eccentric Characters – Elliot, Elena, Mrs. Ivey, Bennet, Darcy, Tory, Matthew, Kim, Alex, Jasper, Dick

Naturally, Elena isn’t solely dealing with Matthew, Tory, and Jasper. She is now interacting with a rather large community from Mrs. Ivey, who has lived at the Greybourne and holds the purse strings for a few living there, down to the teenagers Elliot, Bennet, and Darcy. Now, Elliot takes to Elena quickly, mainly because her room upstairs is down the hall from where he smokes. Bennet and Darcy are the kids of Tory’s husband, Dick, with Bennet being older and Darcy potentially being someone Elliot has a crush on.

Outside the Greybourne, there are other nannies, like Kim and Alex, who share a secret about Elena’s employers, and that is the universe Elena has entered. One in which Dick has a fitting name, his kids are nicer than their biological or step-parent, and Mrs. Ivey? As shown, she can be nice when she wants something, like Elena to spy for her, but in general? She’s a tough cookie.

There Might Be More Here Than Meets the Eye – Jocelyn, Elena, Ginny, Scott

After getting acclimated to her job and living quarters, Elena begins to look for this ruby she is supposed to steal, and with the basement seeming like the perfect place to store such a thing, she uses blueprints she saw in Matthew’s office to investigate. It’s a creepy affair due to no one living down there, and it mostly being abandoned rooms and storage, but with one room seemingly acting as a potential secret meeting room? Elena gets caught in there, stuck for a minute, and once she breaks free, she rushes to get out of the basement and discovers a dead body on her way out.

This leads to the cops coming and us learning Elena’s boyfriend, Scott, is a detective! But, on top of that shock is us learning someone Elena met, Jocelyn, who she thought was one of the nannies in the building; she is a ghost. Which Elena learns from Ginny, the only other nanny we’re told that lives in the building.

Things To Note

Question(s) Left Unanswered

  1. How did Scott and Elena find out about this ruby?
  2. What happened to the note left before the suicide?

What Could Happen Next

  1. Getting additional backstories


Community Rating: 0.00% (0) - No Community Ratings Submitted (Add Yours Below)

On The Fence

It’s Likable But Doesn’t Blow You Away

When it comes to “The Watchful Eye,” it seems to be built upon the usual characters you’d expect from a show like this. The lead is someone with a bit of a chip on their shoulder, there is this precocious kid who is adorable, there is this older woman who isn’t fooled by their ruse, and the list goes on. For the most part, the actors cast and their characters, for this are fine and likable, even comedic at times.

However, “The Watchful Eye” isn’t a comedy. Likability of characters is not a priority. They need to be interesting and drive the story, and I wouldn’t say they accomplish that. Having yet another show of the rich behaving badly and someone not of that world learning about this? We’ve seen this story tons of times.

Which is where “The Watchful Eye” goes wrong in that it doesn’t present anything to make this stand out. Allie’s suicide doesn’t really mean much because we don’t learn a thing about her, and the people who could inspire or push her don’t present a notable hook. And, as we always say for premiere episodes, this is not the period where there were only a few network stations – you need to hit the ground running and not wait around to hook an audience.

So, hopefully, episode two does what episode one doesn’t.

Wallpaper at the Greybourne
The Watchful Eye: Season 1/ Episode 1 “Hen In The Fox House” – Recap/ Review
“The Watchful Eye” starts weak, but it is a mystery. So here is hoping, with a two-episode premiere, it may complete its foundation in the next episode and become worthy of the previews that made this seem interesting.
It’s Likable But Doesn’t Blow You Away

Listed Under Categories: ,

Follow, Like and Subscribe

What Would Your Rating Be?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.