Maniac: Season 1/ Episode 5 “Exactly Like You” – Recap/ Review (with Spoilers)

We come to the end of the Pill B arc and, naturally, with it being Owen’s episode, things transition to addressing his issues – like Olivia. Until Annie upstages him. Network Netflix Director(s) Cary Joji Fukunaga Writer(s) Caroline Williams, Mauricio Katz Air Date 9/21/2018 Characters Introduced Olivia Grace van Patten Images and text in this…

Community Rating: 0.00% (0) - No Community Ratings Submitted (Add Yours Below)

Read our Editorial Guidelines regarding how posts are written and rated and our use of affiliate links.

A toy truck version of the vehicle Ellie died in.

We come to the end of the Pill B arc and, naturally, with it being Owen’s episode, things transition to addressing his issues – like Olivia. Until Annie upstages him.

Director(s) Cary Joji Fukunaga
Writer(s) Caroline Williams, Mauricio Katz
Air Date 9/21/2018
Characters Introduced
Olivia Grace van Patten

Images and text in this post may contain affiliate links which, if a purchase is made from those sites, I may earn money or products from the company. Most affiliate links contain an upward facing, superscript, arrow.

The Setup: Ollie, Arlie, GRTA, Dr. Fujita, Dr. Robert

Time for a shift! We got to 1947, though you could be led to believe we’d be coming on the night Owen lost his marbles with Olivia. However, it is just him being some type of thief whose wife, who left him, Arlie, coming back into his life and getting involved with his case. One in which he plans to steal the lost chapter of Don Quixoteir?source=bk&t=amaall0c 20&bm id=default&l=ktl&linkId=7df7d9708763aa7c9f4d2ff266fc0cd7& cb=1537661199471. Problem is, Dr. Fujita, who is trying to separate Owen and Annie, keeps tossing Annie out only for her to pop right back in. Seemingly because GRTA relates to her in some way or is imprinting on her.

Why? Well, she sees them both as depressed over someone they lost. For Annie, it is Ellie, who is confirmed dead from being crushed and burned to death – surprise! As for GRTA? Well, the death of Dr. Robert, who is in the dream, has her wishing to find a way to bring him back from the dead. Hence the party having a seance theme.


GRTA, in human form, with two odd girls beside her.

So… GRTA is able to go beyond being a bystander and insert herself into the actual dreams. Why do I feel like the past issues of the trial probably wasn’t just Dr. Robert being a drug addict? For if GRTA can get depressed, do you think she got envious of what Dr. Fujita and Dr. James had? Maybe inserted, in human dreams, her getting to be with Dr. Robert dancing, canoodling, having sex, etc? But there is also a need to question who were those two girls by her side?

Switching to Annie, shouldn’t it have been dangerous pulling her out of Owen’s dream world like that? When she went back to the lab and revisited the story about her mother leaving, it seemed violent and she came and went as we have seen Grimsson do. Considering Owen’s already fragile state, did anyone not think this would be dangerous for him? I mean, Annie seems a bit more functional without the trial than him. So you’d think taking her out would lead the world to maybe collapse.

But, then again, this isn’t Reverie and it seems Owen and Annie have 0 control over what happens.

Addressing Linda and Arlie: Dr. James, Annie

Why did Linda and Arlie manifest? Well, Linda represents something foreign to Annie. Something she claims she never wanted but maybe, more so, feared she’d never have. After all, her mother did quite a number on her. So the idea of having three kids and a ride or die husband? Ludicrous.

As for Paula? Well, that is Greg’s mom and the whole idea was stopping Greg’s death so Ellie would have never died. But, with her saying something to the effect of “No matter who I had to hurt” it makes you wonder if she would have killed to get what she wanted. Like, in the case of Patricia, would she have actually killed her to get into this trial? If not, more so, hurt her daughter for not letting her in? For while it is established Annie isn’t suicidal, homicidal isn’t brought up.

Leading to the need to address Arlie – this is Annie’s manifestation of her mother. Someone who liked to make deals, have you let your guard down, and then gut you. Now, as for whether Arlie and Ollie’s relationship was like how it was between her parents? That isn’t said.


Annie being interview by Dr. James.

If Ellie is dead, what is in Salt Lake City waiting for Annie? She had no intention of talking to their mom and their dad is… well seemingly in a similar state to GRTA. So is she buried in Salt Lake City? Also, why does it seem there was more to Annie’s mom than there appears? Not to throw the unreliable narrator idea into the mix, since Ellie did co-sign Annie’s experiences to a point, but there are details here which feel like they are lacking.

Plus, it does seem like GRTA is glitching and considering she is in people’s minds, who knows if, as she observes things, she may not be reconfiguring memories as well. After all, the sell here is these three pills, taken over the course of three days, are supposed to be more effective than therapy. So who is to say GRTA, a depressed AI, doesn’t just delete whatever hurt you. If not takes the emotion out of it so you feel unaffected?

Because, with what we’ve seen thus far, what else could she really do. We see her interfere, to a point, this episode but not enough to say she is trying to influence either Annie or Owen’s brain. It seemed, if anything, she was trying to connect to them. She wanted to connect to Annie and grieve with her over a loss one or connect with Owen over the ideas of being tricked, betrayed, or having something potentially stolen. So will the trial ultimately fail?

Meanwhile…: Ollie, Olivia, GRTA, Arlie

In the long run, despite it seeming Ollie is a thief, the proper word would be “was.” After Arlie betrayed him, drugged him, and he went to prison, it seems he decides to work on the other side. That is, testing people’s security systems as he does for GRTA for her last chapter of Don Quixote. But, to get it, he needed Arlie and Olivia gives some help. However, despite this being Owen’s episode, he still lags behind the progress Annie has made.


Ollie taking note he expected Arlie to betray him, but hoped for the best.
Ollie/Owen: My problem is I let you get too close.

What is going to be done with Owen? At this point, it seems the writers have decided to exploit Emma Stone and Annie to the fullest and make Owen but a supporting character. Which I’m fine with, since Owen blew it on episode 1. However, we’re halfway in now and with meeting Olivia, I must admit I’m hoping they’ll address the peculiarities of that relationship more. Especially whether it was true or not that his parents set him up or was that just his paranoia. Though, who knows, maybe it wasn’t his parents but Jed? Hence Grimsson’s existence.

Either way, Owen definitely needs a jump start in, preferably, the dream worlds where Hill isn’t playing monotone, unless they are going to give Owen some adrenaline.

Collected Quote(s) & .Gifs

Every mistake I’ve ever made started with “It’s too good to be true.”
— Ollie


  1. It seems we have nearly completed Annie’s background.

Low Points

  1. At this point, does anyone still feel invested in the doctors anymore?

On The Fence

  1. Owen got benched since episode 2, which has allowed Annie to make this show worth watching. So, with her background developed as far as it has, does that mean Owen will be given a chance to catch up? Also, considering how “meh” his family seems, will Owen’s story even match Annie’s at all or just be a sad attempt at making Stone and Hill seem even as leads?

Follow Wherever I Look on Twitter, Like us on Facebook and Subscribe to the YouTube Channel.

[ninja_tables id=”26561″]

Check Out Other TV Recaps

Listed Under Categories:

Follow, Like and Subscribe

What Would Your Rating Be?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.