A picture of David Elster at Anatole's shrine.

5 Comments

  1. Found this show rather late (clearly) and had been absolutely enthralled up until this episode. Suddenly everything took a really strange turn and the writing became almost instantly lazy and forced, with characters acting entirely outside their established behavior to suit the narrative and then bumbling their way to the finale.

    I refuse to accept that Laura…this bold and intelligent lawyer who has been standing up for the rights of synths and understands their short-comings and ways of thinking, is willing to just sit there and blubber about a Sophie’s choice/trolley problem that she then actually makes a decision on?

    The Laura they wrote up to that point wouldn’t have done that. She would have laid it out to them for what it was: an impossible decision that she will refuse to make because she is being held hostage and their threat speaks only to their nature; not hers. She wouldn’t play a party to anyone’s murder. What they choose to do is their responsibility. That’s the entire point of what she’s been fighting for: equal rights and equal responsibility.

    Even if she didn’t get through the leader, the others may have begun to doubt him. I fully expected her to follow that line of reasoning, resulting in Stanley taking action to stop the whole thing, maybe aided by others, maybe with a tragic result of someone innocent being killed, but with everyone intact as the characters they’ve established.

    Really, really stupid and disappointing turn that has changed my mind about recommending this show to friends. It’s like the writers either forgot the ending they had been trying to lead up to and suddenly remembered and didn’t care that it didn’t make sense now, or found out they weren’t getting another season, panicked, and spewed out some slap-dash ending that had to be ham-fisted in. Regardless, I’m not impressed.

  2. Was very disappointed with the writing on season 3 episode 6.
    What a ridiculous outcome for Laura and so out of character for her, did the writers forget who they were writing for.
    1. Laura is a mother, she would protect the young and innocent first.
    2. Laura is devoted to her synth causes sometimes at the expense of her human connections.
    3. Laura would not have given in so quickly and would have tried to reason with Anatole.
    Just felt like this episode was written purely for dramatic purposes alone!

  3. Laura definitely should have chosen the old man to die. That seemed so out of character for her.

  4. I can see that. The show has largely been character driven but now it could be seen as story drive. But, I’d argue the characters they used to drive drama, like Hester, lost their luster quick. By making things more about the story, like Synths as a whole than just this group, it makes things a bit more interesting.

  5. I thought Laura choosing Sam to die was out of character. She’s put her whole family in physical danger for choosing to advocate synth rights. If she had been forced to choose between family and Sam, or if he husband had made the decision, I’d buy it more readily. It just feels like forced drama now and characters submitting to the storyline rather than shaping the story though their character.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.