8 Comments

  1. Sorry to shoot your idea down, Emily, but the cliché of workplace dating in medical dramas developed for a reason… it’s economical, it’s functional. ? And perhaps it is no coincidence that Amari often complains about relationships in this show to be more functional than romantic – it might very well be that the writers are bored by the cliché as well.

    Melendez and Lim hooking up? More convenient than hot sparks, and quickly ended by emotions clashing with duties. Melendez and Claire? Destined to fail because of the same reasons and only saved by the bell (well, it was a little more dramatic). Glassman and his nurse turned barista turned office manager? Clash constantly about work. And let’s not talk about Jared.

    The only functioning relationship (besides the mythical marriage of Andrews) in this hospital is that between Shaun the doctor and Lea the IT director – and we have seen how hard it is for the scripts to find reasons for Lea being in the main plots. “Waiting” and “Decrypt” are prime examples for that. Usually, Lea’s character development is relegated to the C-plots. Next episode requires her to be a medical emergency to be center stage. Being a love interest on The Good Doctor *is* challenging in many ways. Though, being a parent to the main cast has proven to be even more dangerous.

    Now, with Asher I’m still a bit confused about what direction the show will take with him and Claire since he’s seemingly not bisexual but interested in men only. Perhaps the writers thought that Claire needs a friend since Lim draw a professional line between them lately and Shaun is preoccupied with the baby.

    1. Hi Andreas! Don’t worry about shooting my idea down. I think it was more wishful thinking anyway.

      I never thought about how being a parent to the main cast was “more dangerous” (lol!). So far Lea’s parents are the only ones we have met that didn’t need to be hospitalized!

      I’m still hoping for Claire and Asher being just friends with nothing sinister or underlying coming up. But we shall see.

      Actually there is a lot of time to find out about them. ABC, the American network that pays for and shows TGD, has just renewed it for Season 5. So this fall we will have a bunch of new shows to watch and comment on. Yay!!

  2. Hi Emily! Recurring characters as love interests are a bit a catch 22 – they fill the role, but they aren’t in the action of the main plot(s), thus they can be quite shallow or barely developed and a distraction from the important storylines. Also, they tend to be isolated characters because they only interact with their lover.

    That is why medical dramas like to pair main characters – they are always there, they have plenty reasons to interact besides sleeping with each other. It keeps the cast small ant the stories straightforward.

    This show’s cast is already too big to have them all in the spotlight regularly. Another love interest would either worsen the matter or, if shown only rarely, be insignificant. That is the reason I believe the Park/Reznick thng will continue for a while.

    Which would be OK with me, although I too would prefer Claire and Morgan become a thing. Alas, all women of TGD are still totally straight, so that still seems unlikely. In fact, I’m currently a little puzzled by the frequency Claire and Asher are brought together by the scripts… I wonder if this will become important in the following episodes.

    1. Andreas, unfortunately you make some very good points as to why TGD will not be adding a new character as a love interest for Morgan, thus ruining what I previously thought was a great idea. Oh well.

      But you read my mind as to how the writers keep having Claire and Asher share scenes together, like in the OR or when going out for cheeseburgers. They already tried to pair Claire with Enrique(?) and then just ended up writing him off the show. I hope this doesn’t mean they are going to have Claire and Asher start dating. Not every character has to be romantically involved. I would be very happy just watching Claire and Asher grow into becoming best friends, but then that might not be enough drama for TGD, so I’m guessing something will happen to the two of them down the road.

  3. Hi Andreas! I actually thought Lea sneaking up on Shaun’s work crush was kind of cute! But I hope that Morgan does not turn in to a stalker!! That’s one of the reasons why I wish the showrunner would cast someone new for Morgan – to get her to forget all about Park. Now that you reminded me of Morgan breaking into Park’s online account, that is creepy! And it is the first step towards stalking him!

  4. Amari, you noting that Shaun might best connect with Lea about their shared anxieties is quite intriguing. Being anxious is a “basic operation” when living with ASD. A lot of situations, and people can make you anxious. Thoughts that won’t leave you alone make you anxious… Anxiety disorder is a common comorbidity of ASD. I myself tend to bond over shared worries to the point that I often end up being the sounding board and counselor.

    And with the ending of “Waiting” it very much seems like Shaun and Lea’s sync will soon have added another layer. Though, my prospect on the storyline isn’t totally grim since the lyrics that accompanied the various ending scenes were quite talkative again. Morgan got “All on your own” when Park walked away and Claire “Put eager hands to sleep tonight / To dream of places never seen before” when she made a peace offering to Asher.

    Shaun and Lea got “Grace the days, the night, the now / You surely get it by now / That seeds don’t grow without a cloud”, although the last bits were barely audible thanks to Shaun’s cries for help. Yet, it indicates that this “cloud” will blow over.

    What won’t blow over quickly is probably the Morgan-Park connection – sorry Emily! Do you remember the reason why Morgan carries a gun? She had creepy guy stalking her in med school – or that’s the version Morgan told Claire in “Aftermath”. Yet, we know that Morgan likes to “tweak” her stories as she needs them.

    What we know for sure is that Morgan already did break into Park’s Bumble account and monitored his online-hits. Stalking is about being in control and often caused by a rejection. Morgan was definitely hit hard by Park’s rejection at the end of “Waiting” and her character lusts for control… Morgan might give Parks and/or his new flame some special attention. And that would probably less cute than Lea sneaking up on Shaun’s work crush.

  5. Hi Amari! I thought Alex ended it with Morgan in the last episode, but apparently not. Anyway, I hope they stay ended, and Alex doesn’t feel the need to announce his intent to date Heather instead of Morgan every episode. That would get old quickly! With Morgan, I don’t know why the writers can’t introduce someone good looking and with a lot of charisma, like that MMA fighter/patient, for Morgan to date. It can be another doctor or resident or male nurse or even an orderly – just someone that would we could see Morgan falling for that wouldn’t make us roll our eyes every time he appeared onscreen! The writers did it once before with that EMT during the virus outbreak storyline, so they can do it again. As far as Claire goes, I’m fine with her not dating for a while since she’s still getting over the death of Melendez. And Alex can fade into the background with Andrews, like you mentioned in your review.

    I really hope Lea doesn’t have a miscarriage! In fact, let’s just let her have the baby and have the storyline be Shaun adjusting to the huge changes a baby brings about. That’s enough storyline for a whole season or two or three. And I hate, hate hate the thought of killing off Lea!! I have grown to really like Lea, so she needs to live and help Shaun adjust to the baby.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.