Fallout: Season 2 Episode 5 – Recap and Review

Spoiler Alert: This summary and review contains spoilers.

Additionally, some images and text may include affiliate links, meaning we may earn a commission or receive products if you make a purchase.

Episode 5 “The Wrangler” Recap and Details

• Director(s): Liz Friedlander
• Writer(s): Owen Ellickson
• Public Release Date (Prime Video): January 14, 2026
• Check out more of our “Fallout” coverage.

What If I’m The Problem?: Cooper, Barbara, Robert

With knowing what his wife is involved in, Cooper has long held the worry she could be a key to the end of the world, just as much as it has been pushed that Robert could. However, upon going to a party in Vegas, where Barbara is poised to make a deal, Robert House invites Cooper to his penthouse and presents the idea that Cooper could be the key factor in nuclear war.

Now, what led to this? Well, because Robert is a calculated man. Yes, he seems a bit out there, your usual eccentric billionaire type, but he runs the data constantly gathered from his products and licenses to make sure, as his catchphrase goes, “The House Always Wins.” But, while the world was supposed to end on Janey’s birthday, it seems Cooper’s appearance in Vegas moved that up a month.

His influence, just by showing up, isn’t taken lightly and leads Robert to this accusation, and with Cooper slowly but surely getting in over his head, overwhelmed by how real this is all getting, he decides he and Barbara need to talk. Him spying, assuming, apparently playing a pivotal role in something he doesn’t understand, he can’t do it anymore.

Nothing More Dangerous Than Killing A Person’s Dreams: Ronnie, Claudia, Norm

Norm’s secret is officially out, and it was by accident. Claudia, who was only working for Vault-Tec for a week before she found herself cryogenically frozen, bonds with Norm as she opens up about everything and everyone she knows being gone. Him reciprocating her vulnerability by admitting he isn’t Bud’s successor, pushing the idea that Bud’s followers are nuts, doesn’t go well with Ronnie.

Add in Norm is investigating what Future Enterprise Ventures is, aka the Forced Evolutionary Virus, the key to the Fallout games’ Supermutants, things don’t go well. Norm, essentially, gets choked out by Ronnie, while Claudia is in another room, presumably not having set him up, and we’re left to wonder what’s next for him?

Willing To Make A Deal: Snake Oil Salesman, Hank, Lucy, Cooper

The Snake Oil Salesman who you were likely expecting to never see again, ends up at Vault-Tec. Not the one Norm is at, which seems to be one of their other offices, but the one Hank is in. He is found by Hank while Hank is out in the wasteland, and the still unnamed character ends up a willing subject to Hank’s mind control, and unlike the others, he doesn’t die when Hank cranks that up.

So, with Hank needing a proxy, he sends him to meet Lucy and Cooper and negotiates Lucy’s return to the vault for the continued preservation of Barbara and Janey, who are currently in cryogenic stasis at the Vault-Tec facility Hank has been working in. Now, with Lucy assuming, especially after escaping Deathclaws together, she and Cooper are friends and closer than ever; it is a shock that he is more than willing to trade her for the assumption that Hank has his wife and kid.

But, let it be clear, Cooper met Hank at Robert’s party mentioned in the first topic, and he knows who he is. So this isn’t some simple, idle threat. However, with Lucy’s recent turn because of her drug addiction, earlier that day, she not only stole a cure for her addiction (addictol) but also a power fist. So while Cooper may shoot her with a tranquillizer dart, the addictol fended off the effects long enough for her to get revenge by using the powerfist on Cooper, sending him flying from a second-floor window, and getting him stuck due to being impaled.

However, this doesn’t mean Lucy is now free to continue to look for her dad. While the Salesman leaves after Cooper confirms the deal, Hank walks in just before Lucy is completely knocked out. Leaving us to wonder if he, or the salesman, may end up bringing back Lucy to the vault?

New Characters in Episode 5

Claudia (Rachel Marsh)

• Character Summary: Claudia is one of the newest members of Vault-Tec, having only been a week in before she joined Bud’s management trainees in cryogenic stasis, likely for Reclamation Day.

Snake Oil Salesman (Jon Daly)

• Character Summary: Originally met in season 1, the Snake Oil Salesman is part of the reason Thaddeus is now a ghoul and is a very weird guy. Which ended up making him not only the perfect test subject, but perhaps one of the perfect people to be Hank’s personal assistant.

Other Noteworthy Information

• Ma June informs Norm she has seen his sister, and makes it seem to him that she died.
• This episode explains why the Robert House from season 1 looks different from season 2, as the real Robert House has a representative he sends out into the world so he can appear randomly like his favorite role model is Deadpool.

Question(s) Left Unanswered & Predictions

• Lucy heading back to the vaults would probably be the best thing for that storyline, but it does push the need to question how long the vault storyline can last. There is a pending civil war, a water shortage in one area, and it seems everything will have to blow up eventually. So, what will happen beyond Lucy likely looking for her father again? If not joining forces with Norm?
• With mention of the Forced Evolutionary Virus, does this mean we’ll see super mutants?!

Review and Commentary

Highlights

Lucy’s Moral Compass Breaking Under Pressure [83/100]

Lucy being on drugs and not only stealing something she needs, but also something she wanted, essentially breaks that Vault Dweller persona. She snuck into a place, stole two items, killed an admittedly suspicious man, and didn’t apologize, didn’t confess, she just moved on, vomited up her drugs, and met up with Cooper. I like this new Lucy.

But the thing that matters most here is that, if she does end up back at the vaults, this is the type of Lucy who could put an exclamation point into the beginning of the end of that storyline. Whether she plays a role in the upcoming civil war, or simply exposes to everyone what’s going on outside the vaults and upends everything, she is a wild card. One that could, hopefully, put the vault storylines to sleep and allow the show to write off those characters with dignity.

Forced Evolutionary Virus! [81/100]

I will not pretend to be the expert on Fallout lore, but from playing the games and reading spoilers about Fallout 1 and Fallout 2, since they are likely to never be remade with modern technology, the term wasn’t lost on me. It is the key to what are known as Supermutants, and with them often being bizarre, comical, sometimes as violent as Deathclaws, the possibility of them showing up is something to get excited about.

I would even submit that while the show does touch upon lore and locations, it would be a major boon for this show to not just have us see Supermutants, but really dive into the history. For, in my mind, they are underutilizing the flashback feature by solely focusing on Cooper. There is so much they could expand on, and we can only hope that, between the tests Vault-Tec did on people and all the other madness that came from the end of the world, Fallout doesn’t skimp out on some of the more notable history.

On The Fence

Cooper’s Past and Some Of The Lingering Mysteries [77/100]

To be honest, the luster of seeing Cooper’s past and all the mysteries of who started the nuclear war, its waning. Similar to the issue with the vaults, there just aren’t the personalities or storylines that really carry from episode to episode. Yes, you want to know what happened to Barbara, who caused the war, and things like that. But the journey to those answers has become rather tedious and honestly, Cooper as a Ghoul holds far more value than his past as a smooth skin.

Also, Barbara hasn’t been built up for long-term investment. She is powerful, but we’ve gotten only a few moments of them showing her being so. The rest of the time, she is name-dropped, and it undercuts what she could really add to Cooper’s past.

The Issue Of Seasonal v. Long Term Storylines [74/100]

Perhaps the major issue with Fallout at this point is that a lot of its anchor characters don’t feel built for long-term storylines. Cooper and Lucy’s storyline works, for it not only mirrors what you often see in the game, but with Cooper being the first ghoul treated like a main character, Lucy being new to the Wasteland, and Hank’s work, each one has a hook. It gives you not only a storyline for the season, but also allows room to theorize or fantasize what’s next for them in future seasons.

The same goes for Maximus, who was absent this episode, considering the wealth of things that can be done with The Brotherhood of Steel. But then comes Norm, and the other vault dwellers left behind. I’d even add Cooper’s past to this. Norm’s storyline may have the flexibility that comes with a lack of expectation, but the increasingly apparent issue of this show is that, while Fallout has a lot of weird characters, who look notable, it doesn’t have an abundance of actors whose performances can compensate for potential, or lack thereof, in their storylines.

Cooper’s past feels like it is bread-crumbing us, and while Norm is stumbling upon projects which can pique the ears of fans of Fallout lore, the show has proven itself to want to be part of the world of Fallout, but not coerced to relive everything that was shown or happened in the games. Which it shouldn’t, as it is not a direct adaptation. However, season 2 has been average, at best, because there is this push and pull between honoring what has been established, while forging its own path, and it may need another season to find its balance.

Overall

Our Overall Rating [78/100]

I think the problem for us is more so wanting Fallout to lean into being an adaptation, rather than a show that exists within the world of the games, but wants to selectively distance itself. Which is respectable, for there are a lot of ways it could go for easy wins by recreating storylines from the game, including the more niche ones.

But, by forging an unpaved path, as much as you want to applaud the desire to be unique, it is difficult not wish it took easy wins more often as it becomes clear not all characters or stories are given equal quality.

What To Check Out Next

Visit our main TV shows page! There you’ll find other shows we’ve covered or look below for more of our coverage for this series:

TV Shows We’re Covering This Season