Fallout: Season 2 Episode 3 – Recap and Review

Fallout continues to use murder and gore to keep things interesting as it appears to want a slow burn to something major.

ByAmari Allah Hours Posted on

Spoiler Alert: This summary and review contains spoilers.

Additionally, some images and text may include affiliate links, meaning we may earn a commission or receive products if you make a purchase.

Episode 3 “The Profligate” Recap and Details

  • Director(s): Liz Friedlander
  • Writer(s): Chaz Hawkins
  • Public Release Date (Prime Video): December 31, 2025
  • Check out more of our “Fallout” coverage.

Trying To Keep Your Hands Clean In A Dirty World: Lucy, Cooper, Charlie, Robert, Victor, Captain Rodriguez,

While Lucy left Cooper to die, eventually he gets back on his feet, and after discovering she entered Caesar’s Legion’s camp, he knows she’ll need backup. After all, Lucy, after making it clear she isn’t a virgin, and watching the girl she helped get killed, ended up on a crucifix, left to die. So, Cooper thought he’d get the NCR (New California Republic) to help, but outside of Captain Rodriguez, a securitron, and someone who seems a bit shell-shocked, they barely exist in the area.

Luckily, like the Brotherhood of Steel, things are tense in Caesar’s Legion to the point they split in half after the actual Caesar died. Mind you, he named a successor, but with the name in his pocket, and no one allowing anyone to go into his pocket, the camp split between the original Caesar’s Legion and simply, The Legion. Cooper trades information on the NCR’s location for Lucy, and blows up some of their dynamite to protect Captain Rodriguez, who seemingly is familiar with Cooper. But, with blowing up that dynamite means the two legions finally go to battle.

Which leads to our episodic flashback of you wondering, did Barb intentionally leave Cooper behind and go into a vault with their kid? When it comes to Robert House, how could someone be so rich, so weird, so rude, walk around without security, and yet have no bruises from being punched in the face? It’s hard to say.

The only thing that can be said for sure is that Cooper being tasked with killing Robert is something he is looking for anyone to convince him not to do, but even his good friend Charlie doesn’t seem willing to say that’s crazy.

Are You Trying To Start A War?: Quintus, Maximus, Xander, Thaddeus

Because Xander’s existence brings on such a tense environment, and could be a problem, Maximus asks why can’t he just be killed? Quintus admonishes him publicly, mainly due to being frustrated that his Western alliance fell apart almost as soon as Xander showed up.

But, to make things more trying, Xander seeks to befriend Maximus, goes out and hangs with him, even does a side quest type mission where the two face securitrons together. All is good until they discover the factory Thaddeus now works in, where he has children working around the clock to gather bottle caps – both ghoul and smooth skin kids.

Being that the codex says to eliminate ghoul children, Xander decides to separate the kids, and he is ready to shoot the presumably innocent ghouls, who probably aren’t or barely 10. Maximus stops him by killing him, thus setting up the very thing Quintus feared.

New Characters in Episode 3

Lacerta Legate (Macaulay Culkin)

Lacerta Legate (Macaulay Culkin) – Fallout Season 2 Episode 3
  • Check out other productions we’ve covered starring this actor: [Link to Actor’s Tag]
  • Character Summary: One of the top commanders in The Legion’s military.

Review and Commentary

Highlights

Maximus Becoming Disillusioned With The Brotherhood Again [82/100]

One of the things we appreciate about Maximus’ journey is that he wants rules, order, and wants to believe the system, or any system, can work. Whether it is the codex or Quintus’ teachings, despite his desire to believe, trying to work within the system, it keeps failing him. I think, like many, he wants to see someone who claims to be an agent of change, a true leader, come about to bring peace and keep him, and others, from experiencing notable destruction.

Yet, he gets that experience of “Don’t meet your heroes.” From a distance, upon first introduction, he sees someone who could be what he has been hoping for. But like Quintus, now Xander, it seems, mainly with the Brotherhood of Steel, it is revealed that, no matter how good a person they seem, a lust for power will always taint them. The only question is, with Maximus getting more and more powerful, socially and physically, will he end up right on the same path, too?

On The Fence

Minor Notable Moments Surrounded By Filler [76/100]

Maximus killing Xander and Macaulay Culkin showing up in The Legion’s camp were the only notable things that happened. But The Legion v. Caesar’s Legion civil war meant very little since the show barely did much with them besides what it usually does. It made them seem barbaric, selective in terms of right and wrong, even if we’re talking historical context, and seemingly compensated for depth with humor and violence.

Technically, the same thing was done with Xander. He represents the all-powerful Commonwealth chapter of the Brotherhood of Steel, but his time with Maximus was mostly goofy. Yes, he clued in that clerics being in charge is a rare and maybe Quintus chapter-specific thing. Also, he presented the idea that the Commonwealth was too big to fail, and if it ever did, the consequences would be major.

But, again, a famous actor representing a notable faction, with very little done to build beyond the pop of a famous face on the show. Now, yes, both situations end with a war being promised, with us seeing Caesar’s Legion and The Legion facing off. However, who cares who wins in that scenario?

The Brotherhood of Steel going to war, though, especially considering all of their weapons involved? That could be interesting. Granted, it’s hard to say how interesting since, outside of Maximus and Dane, anyone else dying wouldn’t feel like a notable, or terrible loss. But, the more we watch Fallout, the more it seems to lean into one of the video game’s selling points of being notably gory at times, so I guess we’re more meant to look forward to that than anything else.

Overall

Our Overall Rating [79/100]

It feels far too soon to call this a sophomore slump. But I do think, like a lot of video game adaptations, see The Last of Us, things went so well in season 1, that season 2 appears less than because it is no longer new, shiny, or going against the odds of so many bad video game adaptations. Now, there aren’t low standards but normal or even high standards, and it isn’t reaching that pedestal.

To make things a bit more difficult for Fallout, it is placed in the Fallout universe, but only minor characters actually exist in the game, like Robert House. The overwhelming majority are original, so it can’t fully live off just adapting the same story, sometimes dialogue, and characters, as The Last of Us is doing. Plus, with it venturing past where players left off in Fallout: New Vegas, it is also balancing avoiding making a definitive ending, while each season works towards an epic finale.

So while we’re not as excited as we were before, I wouldn’t say Fallout has gotten bad as much as it has lost its luster and has become average.

What To Check Out Next

Visit our main TV shows page to see other shows we’ve covered or check out our latest coverage for “Fallout” below!

TV Shows We’re Covering This Season

Listed Under Categories:
Related Tags: , , , , ,

Amari is the founder and head writer of Wherever-I-Look.com and has been writing reviews since 2010, with a focus on dramas and comedies.