The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel: Season 2/ Episode 3 “The Punishment Room” – Recap/ Review (With Spoilers)

Miriam at Mary's wedding reception.
100% (1)

As Abe and Joel hold their recent changes steady, Miriam realizes her social etiquette is going out the window and Susie? Well, she is just tired of being broke.


Network
Amazon Prime
Director(s)Scott Ellis
Writer(s)Daniel Palladino
Air Date12/4/2018

Images and text in this post may contain affiliate links which, if a purchase is made from those sites, I may earn money or products from the company. Most affiliate links contain an upward facing, superscript, arrow.

 

Money Troubles: Susie, Miriam

You know what is frustrating? Having a client who has money. Because of that, they lack drive, literal hunger, and that is what is causing Susie a whole lot of issues. For here is Miriam, living the high life and Susie can’t pay a telephone bill. Add in Miriam is constantly late and talking about finding $2000 and it makes her unwilling to use her girls to impress a guy something to get pissed about. After all, damn how it will look, Susie needs to make a piece of the pie Miriam could be bringing in.

Luckily, while prepping to sell her records, she learns someone taped Miriam and the boys have been selling the record. Meaning Susie now has a bone to pick with those guys.

The Consistency Holds: Joel, Archie, Abe, Rose, Shirley, Moishe

Shirley asking if there will be another Great Depression.
Shirley: Is there gonna be another Great Depression soon?

Joel continues to get his parents finances together by doing his mother’s treasure hunts. Long story short, from their house to the factory, even Miriam’s apartment, his parents have hidden money. I’m talking thousands of dollars since neither seem to trust banks all that much. You know, because they lived through the great depression.

But, luckily, despite Shirley and Moishe acting up at the bank, this includes Shirley talking about bribe money and Moishe making a big deal about finding Jewish people in the bank, Archie comes to the rescue! He convinces his cousin to give Joel a loan and Joel, during the treasure hunt, finds a place in the factor to maybe make into his apartment. Which, with plans to buy the building, should be feasible.

As for Abe and Rose? Oh, things couldn’t be better. Well, they do hit a rough patch with Rose damn near emptying the art department by asking the girls what they plan to do after graduating. However, Abe defends her to the chair of the department and kind of calls out the chairperson as well. What is the point of the 16 or so girls being in a department that doesn’t have female teachers? What are they doing for girls who are in a profession that won’t lead to lucrative results? They’re all valid questions and while the chairperson is ready to stop Rose from auditing classes because she ask that of the girls, and they are ready to leave the program, Abe ends that discussion.

Societal Etiquette: Miriam, Mary

Miriam has been working on balancing out her life. That is, being this sweet, well off, Jewish girl from a good upbringing and being able to roll with the raunchy culture of the clubs and comics. However, trying to keep these two worlds apart, despite them being everything which surmises Miriam, it is getting rather difficult. Take Mary’s wedding and reception. That girl who is unaccustomed to hearing “No” and anything but the best gets Mary a nice wedding and reception room – without money exchanging hands.

However, that same girl embarrasses herself, and Mary, at the reception. Such as making it clear Mary is having a shotgun wedding. Leading to Mary disavowing Miriam a bit and Miriam, as she begs for forgiveness, being downgraded back to the switchboard. Pushing the idea, her two worlds need to come together or else one may die for the other.

Other Noteworthy Facts & Moments

  • Harry and Susie cross paths this episode but no word is said over the alleged calling of goons.

Highlights

Abe and Rose

Abe siding with Rose.
Abe: You know, basically, I think I’m on her side.

There was just something about Abe ready to defend Rose to his colleague over apologizing for her that just hit me in a special place. What I mean by that is, as much as you recognize Abe is just trying to get Rose to stay in New York, it doesn’t seem like his motive is purely selfish. With him showing some sort of understanding behind Rose’s thought process, and how aggressive he was being with the chairperson, you got this sense that he and Rose were a team. That their relationship has truly shifted and likely will stay that course.

Code Switching In A Different Light

When code-switching is usually brought up, it is because of Black and Brown people, as well as LGBTQIA, trying to blend into a surrounding. However, as shown by Midge, there are other situations. Now, maybe they aren’t as life and death, as it is for the aforementioned, but that is one of the unique things The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel brings. For Miriam, she has to code switch to do the thing she loves for while it is fine that her appearance is that of a well to do housewife, that is the Trojan Horse to her raunchy style.

Yet, with living a dual life, we’re starting to see that strain. Whether Miriam likes it or not, they are starting to bleed into one another. She, with her desire to practice her standup whenever in a public place, can’t maintain her posh attitude anymore. Yet, while saying that, you have to recognize her privilege. For if this simply is who Miriam is becoming, it won’t stop opportunities from coming her way. Hell, it is the reason so many take an interest in her.

However, you see what having the same mouth and being funny does for Susie right? Can you imagine the Black girl who works in the makeup department getting away with talking like that? Nope. So while you are given the opportunity to show code-switching isn’t just for a handful of groups, you are reminded that for some it is life and death and others, it is just something to get what you want more easily.

A Reminder That Life Isn’t Roses For Everyone

While it sucks to see Susie struggling, she is the only real reminder that there are normal people in this show’s universe. Joel is getting major loans at the bank, Miriam has the ability to live with her parents, work, and do comedy. Rose went off to Paris just because New York was stressing her out and her family flew over to get her back. When it comes to most of this show, we’re dealing with what looks like the rich.

Susie telling Miriam she broke.
Susie: Think about my life for a moment. I’m broke.

However, Susie helps remind us there are normal people too. In fact, she is the only one really pushing Miriam towards the end goal of becoming a prominent comic. After all, with Miriam being late, and heavily reliant on Susie to get things done, if she was on her own it would take 8 seasons for Miriam to make it. With Susie? Well, maybe 3 or 4. With making it meaning Miriam on television and not for a feminine product commercial.

Follow Wherever I Look on Twitter, Like us on Facebook and Subscribe to the YouTube Channel.


Check Out Other TV Recaps


Season/ EpisodeSynopsisEpisode Information

Season 2/ Episode 6 “Let’s Face The Music and Dance”

Abe learns it isn’t only Miriam with a secret and Joel joins Miriam in beginning to move on.

Director(s)Daniel Palladino
Writer(s)Daniel Palladino
Air Date12/4/2018
Introduced This Episode
LeahMolly Brown

Season 2/ Episode 5 “Midnight at the Concord”

This is the episode where Miriam’s secret leaves being something just known by her comedy friends and enters her personal life.

Director(s)Amy Sherman-Palladino
Writer(s)Amy Sherman-Palladino
Air Date12/4/2018
Introduced This Episode
ChesterConnor Ratliff

Season 2/ Episode 4 “We’re Going To The Catskills”

It’s almost an uneventful episode until Rose hooks up Miriam with a man, a doctor, named Benjamin.

Director(s)Daniel Palladino
Writer(s)Daniel Palladino
Air Date12/4/2018
Introduced This Episode
BenjaminZachary Levi

Season 2/ Episode 3 “The Punishment Room”

As Abe and Joel hold their recent changes steady, Miriam realizes her social etiquette is going out the window and Susie? Well, she is just tired of being broke.

Director(s)Scott Ellis
Writer(s)Daniel Palladino
Air Date12/4/2018

Season 2/ Episode 2 “Mid-Way to Mid-Town”

Miriam has her first paid gig but the camaraderie she got from Lenny Bruce is missing. As that happens, Abe and Joel pull a 180 in their lives.

Director(s)Amy Sherman-Palladino
Writer(s)Amy Sherman-Palladino
Air Date12/4/2018

Season 2/ Episode 1 “Simone”

Miriam is back and as she helps Abe with the fact Rose is in Paris, she mourns her marriage for, perhaps, the final time.

Director(s)Amy Sherman-Palladino
Writer(s)Amy Sherman-Palladino
Air Date12/4/2018

Season 1/ Episode 8 “Thank You and Good Night”

Ladies and Gentlemen, coming to the stage, at last, The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel!

Director(s)Amy Sherman-Palladino
Writer(s)Amy Sherman-Palladino
Characters Introduced
EddieRic Stoneback

Season 1/ Episode 7 “Put That On Your Plate!”

If you were perhaps wondering what would slow down Midge’s career so that she had something to work for in the second season, we get our answer.

Director(s)Daniel Palladino
Writer(s)Daniel Palladino
Characters Introduced
Sophie LennonJane Lynch
David BumenthalZach Appelman

Season 1/ Episode 6 “Mrs. X at the Gaslight”

Susie finds herself having to adapt more to midge as it becomes clear she isn’t the only one who recognizes her talent.

Director(s)Scott Ellis
Writer(s)Sheila Lawrence
Characters Introduced
RandallNate Corddry
AstridJustine Lupe
NoahWill Brill

Season 1/ Episode 5 “Doink”

What’s a word Midge doesn’t often associate with herself? Failure. One she gets a huge heaping of this episode.

Director(s)Amy Sherman-Palladino
Writer(s)Daniel Palladino
Characters Introduced
Mary PetruscaErin Darke
VivianLilli Stein
Mrs. O’TooleJoanna Glushak
HarrietWakeema Hollis
JackieBrian Tarantina
Herb SmithWallace Shawn

Season 1/ Episode 4 “The Disappointment of the Dionne Quintuplets”

In order to take a step forward, you gotta take a step back and Midge pretty much leaps back to where she was in life before she met Joel. 

Director(s)Amy Sherman-Palladino
Writer(s)Amy Sherman-Palladino
Characters Introduced
Jane JacobsAlison Smith
PennyHolly Curran
LanieHarry Zittel
Howard FawnAaron Serotsky
Marty KahnSteve Rosen
Red SkeletonAllen Lewis Rickman

Season 1/ Episode 3 “Because You Left”

Midge makes a firm decision on the direction her life is going in, and it sure as hell isn’t being the so thankful wife anymore.

Director(s)Daniel Palladino
Writer(s)Daniel Palladino
Characters Introduced
Michael KesslerMax Casella
Harry DrakeDavid Paymer

Season 1/ Episode 2 “Ya Shivu v Bolshom Dome Na Kholme”

Advertisements

The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel officially begins and after being haunted by the idea of being single, she realizes how much better off she’ll be without Joel

Director(s)Amy Sherman-Palladino
Writer(s)Amy Sherman-Palladino
Characters Introduced
DrinaMary Testa
ShirleyCaroline Aaron
ZeldaMatilda Szydagis
MoisheKevin Pollak

Season 1/ Episode 1 “Pilot”

The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel is probably one of the few shows Amazon has put on their slate, besides Mozart in the Jungle which makes you believe they are serious about producing compelling, funny, and original productions.

How Would You Rate This?

Negative Mixed Positive

About Amari Sali 3365 Articles
New Jersey native Amari Sali takes the approach of more so being a media advisor than a critic to sort of fill in the gap left between casual fans of media and those who review productions for a living. Thus being open about bias while still giving enough insight, often with spoilers, to present whether something is worth seeing, buying, renting, streaming, or checking out at all.

Be the first to comment

Questions, Comments, or Opposing Opinion?

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.