The Good Doctor: Season 4/ Episode 3 “Newbies” – Recap/ Review (with Spoilers)

In “Newbies,” we are introduced to 6 characters, of which 4 will continue – which ones will join “The Good Doctor” and potentially become regulars?

Morgan and Claire pausing from a disagreement

In “Newbies,” we are introduced to 6 characters, of which 4 will continue – which ones will join “The Good Doctor” and potentially become regulars?

Director(s) David Straiton
Writer(s) Thomas L. Moran, David Renaud
Aired (ABC) 11/16/2020
Introduced This Episode
Jordan Bria Henderson
John Michael Liu
Asher Noah Galvin
Olivia Summer Brown
Will Sam Robert Muik
Enrique Brian Marc

This content contains pertinent spoilers. Also, images and text may contain affiliate links, which, if a purchase is made, we’ll earn money or products from the company.


Meet The New Kids – Jordan, John, Asher, Olivia, Will, Enrique

So the candidates are Will, who is well connected, knowledgeable, but a bit problematic due to him cutting people off and mansplaining – which neither Morgan nor Claire like. Following him is Enrique, who is worldly, but his relaxed attire does put off Claire. Though, one could submit the calm and kindness he shows is very much like how Claire is when she isn’t stressed out.

Following them is Olivia, who is as educated as Will, but with insecurity oozing from every statement, so comes the question if she can ever be assertive? Making her too almost like Claire, in her early days on the show. This brings us to Jordan, who, following the “mirror-universe” approach Andreas mentioned (check out the comment section of previous episodes), gives you a mix of Morgan with Claire when she started to get too assertive for Dr. Melendez’s taste.

Leaving John and Asher. Considering how quiet he is, you almost are left to wonder if John is similar to Shaun, but higher functioning, or displaying autism differently. However, him being reserved more so stems from his concept of what professionalism is – which he thinks most do not display. Then with Asher, there is an intensity there that is mostly in his look. However, with his eagerness and keen eye, you can see a bit of Shaun, a bit of Morgan, almost like those two had a child. One social awkward but willing to take initiative, child.

The Multiday Interview – Jordan, John, Asher, Olivia, Will, Enrique, Lea, Shaun, Claire, Morgan, Dr. Lim, Dr. Andrews, Alex, Dr. Glassman

When it comes to the potential first years, they are split between Dr. Andrews, Shaun, Alex, and Dr. Lim, with Claire. Under Dr. Andrews’ team is Jordan, John, and Enrique, who all bring something different to the team. John brings medical knowledge and eye that rivals Shaun. Hence him saving their patient’s life. However, what John has in medical prowess he lacks in being able to deal with Shaun after he offends Lea.

You see, while John doesn’t like to get personal, Jordan has no issue doing so. She questions Dr. Andrews in front of a patient looking for breast augmentation, and after Shaun says he likes Lea’s body but isn’t fond of her voice, she checks him as well. This leads to Shaun talking to Dr. Glassman and figuring out where he went wrong, since Lea did get upset, but between Dr. Glassman and Enrique’s encouragement, Lea and Shaun reconcile.

As for Dr. Lim’s team? Well, Morgan and Claire going back and forth eclipses Will, Asher, and Olivia to a large degree. In fact, they are often thrown into their spat or, in the case of Will, join in uninvited. But, like with Dr. Andrews’ patient, we get a miraculous solution that allows the patient to live.

The Final Decision – Shaun, Claire, Dr. Lim, Dr. Andrews, Alex

So who gets to stay and who is asked to go? Well, there are some twists and turns with that. Initially, Will was a shoo-in because of how hard Dr. Lim pushed for him, with Jordan following since Dr. Andrews loves how assertive she is. Thus leaving John because of his knowledge and Asher, because he was just generally well-liked.

However, John drops out because he just can’t deal with being expected to listen and deal with relationship drama. Then with Will, Claire opens up about thinking he would be insufferable and taking note of Alex saying they should pick someone they can stand to be around, Will doesn’t make the cut. Thus making the final four: Jordan, Asher, Olivia, and Enrique.

Things To Note | Question(s) Left Unanswered

  1. So, should we consider the first two episodes simply a nod to the COVID pandemic but not necessarily in the show’s regular timeline?

Collected Quote(s) & .Gifs

You’re big on opinions, how are you with ideas?
— Dr. Andrews

It’s better to show my love than try to explain it.
— Shaun


Community Rating: 0.00% (0) - No Community Ratings Submitted (Add Yours Below)


With New Residents Comes A Feeling of Renewal [87]

Despite noting nearly half remind you of Claire or Morgan during their development, their existence shakes things up immensely. Dare I say it, the idea of new characters brings new energy to a show that was starting to feel rather routine. For whether it was the patient of the week, Shaun’s relationship drama, Claire losing the person who finally got her to open up, and then spiraling, it all felt like an endless cycle.

However, with new blood comes the inability to maintain those old cycles since everyone has been promoted to act as supervisors. Hence, John’s inclusion to remind you that a lot of what goes on isn’t professional nor appropriate. Yet, because the lead cast live in this cocoon, what is strange to outsiders are normal to them. Hence why Dr. Andrews going from wanting Shaun fired to just giving him a proverbial hand slap.

But now, we’re given these strong personalities in Jordan and Asher who will challenge the status quo, people like Enrique who will break up expectations, and then Olivia? Well, I foresee her possibly becoming to Morgan what she wanted to have with Claire. Especially if they are allowed to bond over coming from an accomplished family and trying to forge their own path to relevancy amongst them.

Thrilling Surgeries [85]

While Morgan’s patient I can’t recall the name of, and the girl Shaun was over not being much more than a catalyst, I must admit the ins and outs of them being diagnosed and their surgeries were thrilling! Which I haven’t said in who knows how long since the medical aspect of The Good Doctor had long become boring since patients lacked oomph. Alongside that, rarely knowing, if ever, a patient would be lost, it took away any rush, thrill, or need to fear. For, as seen with John’s discovery, someone will discover something minor or come up with an out-there procedure to save the day.

Yet, and I attribute this to the new faces, with them shaking up what has become the norm, there is an excitement that I think could only come from people who could and are likely to make mistakes.

This Claire v. Morgan Rivalry [86]

Claire and Morgan have had a love/hate relationship since Morgan was introduced. If it isn’t a personality clash issue, it is because Morgan got a little too close and chummy, so Claire felt the need to push her away. Now it seems Morgan’s desire to still feel connected to the surgical team bugs Claire as if she feels like Morgan is a specter trying to take something from her.

This, to us, is probably going to be the driving point of Claire’s development for her difficulty in being close to anyone is the core of her character. I’d even say, similar to what Enrique was talking about with Lea and Shaun’s relationship, in terms of being vulnerable enough to allow someone to see their flaws, that is what Claire is looking for.

However, with Dr. Melendez’s death, I think she has reverted back to wanting to hide rather than venture out and grow close to anyone. Also, lest we forget, it took nearly 3 seasons for those two to come to be. So when it comes to Morgan, maybe by the end of this season something could happen between them? I mean, Dr. Melendez and Claire had a moment that took a long time to develop. Would it be wrong to say, especially after how Claire and Morgan were after Claire’s mother died, they could have something by the end of this season or the next?


Community Rating: 0.00% (0) - No Community Ratings Submitted (Add Yours Below)
This Claire v. Morgan Rivalry - 86%
Thrilling Surgeries - 85%
With New Residents Comes A Feeling of Renewal - 87%


With new characters comes a show which finds its second leg after starting to feel like it was on a steady decline.

Subscribe To Hear About Our Latest Posts

* indicates required
Email Format

View previous campaigns.

We use a third-party vendor (MailChimp) to send out newsletters featuring the latest posts from our authors. You will be asked to confirm you understand this and confirm you wish to receive e-mails from Wherever I Look.

You can unsubscribe at any time by clicking the link in the footer of our emails. For information about our privacy practices, please visit our website.

We use Mailchimp as our marketing platform. By clicking below to subscribe, you acknowledge that your information will be transferred to Mailchimp for processing.

Follow, Like, and Subscribe

Community Rating: 0.00% (0) - No Community Ratings Submitted (Add Yours Below)

What Would Your Rating Be?

Negative Mixed Positive Recommended


  1. Amari, please don’t put these pictures into my mind! Shaun and Morgan having a baby… that qualifies for a Steven King novel! 🙂 Though, thanks for the shout-out. 😉 Mirroring is indeed a good keyword for the reason the newbies were introduced to the show. Their characters are all designed to mirror certain personality traits of the senior residents, yet in a different mix.

    As you already noted, Amari, the senior residents have some routine in dealing with each other’s quirks after three years, confronting them with their own shortcomings by the younger, eager newbies will give their character development a new kick.

    David Shore already gave in TGDs predecessor House MD a shake-up at the start of season 4 by bringing in new characters. Though, while House MD simply replaced House’s diagnostic team with new characters, this time the newbies are there to augment the regulars. This is an interesting experiment and I’m eager to see how the show manages to allocate the appropriate screen time. I agree with Emily that in episode 403 they did this quite well, they even managed to expand Lea’s character in the process (by the way, people pretending to be ants is a real thing, just google it).

    Outside of me being a die-hard #Shea supporter, I guess we will have to keep a keen eye on Claire and Morgan’s relationship. One episode post GhostMelendez, it is unclear to me in which direction the show is taking Claire.

    Beneath her public display of empathy and kindness, Claire always deployed rather maladaptive coping mechanisms for her various problems. Although she said in the previous episode that Melendez had changed her forever, Claire was almost even more aggressive and short-tempered this episode than after her mother’s death. Again, Claire is driving her peers away. There’s definitely more to come for her in the next episodes and it is an interesting question if Morgan will again play a major role in it.

    Two self-described straight women slowly realizing that they might find comfort in a same-sex relationship would be an intriguing multi-season arc and with Liz Friedman, who is openly lesbian, there is even a writer on the team who could bring much personal insight into the story.

  2. I’ll start with I think I goofed with the “Submit Rating”. I meant to submit a “Positive” rating, but I think it came out “Mixed” even though my “Overall Opinion” is definitely “Positive”. Oops!

    I did not think this episode would go well and there would be no time for much of anything with our main cast because of all of the time the newbies would take up. But then I saw when they got rid of Debbie, Kellen, Mia, and Dr. Melendez, that freed up a lot of time for Shaun and Lea, Claire and Morgan, and Glassman and Morgan plus Glassman and Shaun. I would love it if every episode was like that!

    I really like the newbies, too! It does shake things up! And now that I can see how they won’t take over the show, I’m very curious to see what will happen with them next!

    To answer your unanswered question, I read an interview with the executive producer, and he said just the first 2 episodes would be during the COVID pandemic. Then starting with tonight’s episode, the episodes take place in a world where there is no pandemic yet still in The Good Doctor timeline (as evidenced by Morgan’s condition, Shaun and Lea’s romance, Dr. Lim and Claire getting to know each other better, etc.)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.