Carnival Row: Season 1, Episode 4 “The Joining of Unlike Things” – Recap, Review (with Spoilers)

Hamlyn (Dejan Bucin) being seen as Vignette is warned about him.
0.00% (0) - No Community Ratings Submitted.

As a name is given to the beast which haunts the shadows, Agreus makes a deal with Imogen and Vignette is put in a life or death situation.


Network
Amazon Prime
Director(s) Thor Freudenthal, Anna Foerster
Writer(s) Travis Beacham, Marc Guggenheim, Peter Cameron
Air Date 8/30/2019
Introduced This Episode
Ritter Longerbane Ronan Vibert
Sophie Caroline Ford
Hamlyn Dejan Bucin
Mima Sawsaan Mina Andala

Images and text in this post may contain affiliate links which, if a purchase is made, we’ll earn money or products from the company. Affiliate links and external links have an upward facing, superscript, arrow.

Recap

A Life For A Life: Mima Sawsaan, Haruspex, Philo

Picking back up on the case from episode 2, Philo speaks with Mima Sawsaan, a holy woman, about what might have attacked Aisling? For he runs into the being and can’t identify it. Thus leading to the term “Darkasher” being revealed and Philo being directed to the same Haruspex that Piety uses. Leading him to learn about what is essentially like Frankenstein’s monster. A golem which is a combination of two and usually required a sacrifice to make.

But, to prove its existence, Philo has one made for himself and, so it seems, he is raped to make the golem and later it is revealed how the golems work. First, they can only die when their master does, and the extent of their connection isn’t limited to life force. The master can also connect with their golem in terms of sight and motor skills. Leading to the question of who is using a golem to kill people and why?

It’s Politics: Piety, Jonah, Ritter, Sophie, Absalom, Imogen, Ezra, Agreus

Piety pushes Absalom closer and closer to the edge, to the point he snaps. On the parliament floor, with little evidence, he throws around the accusation that his opposition leader, Ritter Longerbane, kidnapped his son and is holding him. Which, at first, is just treated as a lapse in judgment. However, as Ritter learns his progressive daughter, Sophie, wishes to go to college, travel more, go against the grain, he is arrested. Later, Piety even poisons him and then reveals where Jonah is being held. Showing that she is a far greater danger than perhaps any other character met.

Sophie (Caroline Ford) talking to her dad about going to college.

Though, of course, not all political matters are about murder and accusations. There also are social politics. Such is the case for Agreus who, purely out of curiosity, accepts Imogen’s invite for tea. Mostly since he wants to see if she is playing a game or not. However, upon hearing the financial status of Ezra and Agreus from a friend, so do the wheels turn of how he can make an arrangement which benefits him and Imogen’s family.

For The Love Of You: Ms. Fyfe, Philo, Vignette, Tourmaline, Dahlia, Hamlyn

Ms. Fyfe, for quite some time, has wanted to take her and Philo’s relationship beyond him renting a room from her and them occasionally having sex. The problem is, he was always distant. Presenting this sort of, it’s not you, it’s me, and trying to be one hand up her skirt and another out the door. But then that changes, for some reason. Maybe it is because he forgives himself when it comes to Vignette? Be it because he paid off her indentured servitude, having this belief they could never be, then or now, or saving her life and returning a memento to her. One of these, among many unnamed reasons, pushes Philo to try his hand at love again.

Leaving Vignette in a bit of a pickle. Her life keeps ending up in Philo’s orbit, and as he tries to absolve himself of guilt, it leads to Dahlia worrying she is a turncoat and being that Dahlia handles issues with urgency, Vignette is in trouble. Especially since Philo’s timing coincides with there being an issue with a supply run. Making it seem Vignette is the cause.

However, Tourmaline, despite her not being fond of Philo, gets him involved and he helps set up Hamlyn to go down. But, with Dahlia, things aren’t simply pointing a finger and that being it. Dahlia wants to be sure, so she asks of Vignette to kill Hamlyn. A task which, initially, was difficult since Vignette has never killed one of her own. Yet, what truly makes the task difficult is Vignette doesn’t take him out when she gets the chance, so they end up fighting in the air, and when they hit ground, he nearly kills her. At least until Philo, as mentioned above, saves her life with a well-placed bullet.

Review

Question(s) Left Unanswered

  1. Who or what is the Darkasher made of? Are they notable or just two random people?

Highlights

Agreus and Imogen Coming To An Understanding

The underestimated and disenfranchised are often unnamed on Carnival Row, except for Agreus and Imogen. So while it is begrudgingly on her part, at the same time I can’t wait to see what comes of them working together. Particularly the awkwardness this might produce because Agreus doesn’t appear to have much in the way of social etiquette skills.

Not in the form of him making loud slurping noises, but more so he seems not to take slights well and has quite the temper. So I’m looking forward to seeing how high society handles a well-spoken faun who has an anger issue. Much less, what their reaction will be since let’s not pretend police brutality isn’t an issue on this show.

Philo & Vignette

Increasingly it is clear this show isn’t going to make Philo and Vignette getting back together a quick and easy journey. For one, both have feelings they are struggling to navigate when it comes to how things ended. For Philo, it is lying and saying he died, dealing with his position in society, and what sacrifices he’ll have to make in order to be with Vignette. Hence Ms. Fyfe being chosen for she is the safe choice. Being with her means digging his heels into this ruse he built and reinforcing it.

Then with Vignette, she is living in a place where she is an other. A place in which her using her wings could get her arrested, maybe her wings sheared off. Heck, all things considered, where outside the brothel have we even seen pixies? Dahlia mentions she was a lady’s maid at one time, but I have yet to see one.

So, taking note of how terrible her world is, can she ask of Philo to sacrifice his privilege? Much less, he lied to her and abandoned her. Made her feel like a widow. How can you reconcile him being alive with the grand betrayal of him not even respecting you enough to say goodbye or break up with you properly? For, in a way, that is what he did. He faked his death to escape her. Mind you, so she wouldn’t do anything foolish, but still.

Low Point

The Political Party Drama

Ritter (Ronan Vibert) listening to his progressive daughter.

One of the major issues with the political drama of this show is that no one seems all that powerful on this show. They have a family name which holds clout, but that’s it. Otherwise, how in the world would Longerbane end up in a dank prison? Never mind be accused, or poisoned, without an uproar? None of these people seem to truly matter and their political parties? Who are those people? What are their names, positions, and ambitions? Are you telling me none of them have their own plans to be chancellor or the opposition leader? Are they just hype men in the back?

On The Fence

The Black Raven

I think I may have hoped for too much. In my mind, Dahlia was going to take Vignette under her wings, mold her in her image, and we’d see Vignette and Philo firmly be on opposing sides of the law. However, considering how Dahlia nearly killed Vignette, and Vignette seeming like more of a lover than a fighter, can you imagine her sticking around? Her fighting for someone who, on a whim, maybe because she is feeling paranoid, would kill a subordinate? I can’t.

Follow Wherever I Look on Twitter, Like us on Facebook, Sign Up For Our Mailing List and Subscribe to the YouTube Channel.

Carnival Row Directory

Creator

Travis Beacham, René Echevarria

Character Guide

Created

Collected Quotes

Not Created

Current Status

Active

Join Amazon Prime - Watch Thousands of Movies & TV Shows Anytime - Start Free Trial Now

Season Reviews

Season 1 (Storylines & Major Arcs)
Check Out The TV Series & Specials Page
Season/ EpisodeSynopsisEpisode InformationTopics & Focused Characters
Season 1, Episode 4 "The Joining of Unlike Things"As a name is given to the beast which haunts the shadows, Agreus makes a deal with Imogen and Vignette is put in a life or death situation.
Director(s) Thor Freudenthal, Anna Foerster
Writer(s) Travis Beacham, Marc Guggenheim, Peter Cameron
Air Date 8/30/2019
Introduced This Episode
Ritter Longerbane Ronan Vibert
Sophie Caroline Ford
Hamlyn Dejan Bucin
Mima Sawsaan Mina Andala
  • A Life For A Life: Mima Sawsaan, Haruspex, Philo
  • It’s Politics: Piety, Jonah, Ritter, Sophie, Absalom, Imogen, Ezra, Agreus
  • For The Love Of You: Ms. Fyfe, Philo, Vignette, Tourmaline, Dahlia, Hamlyn
Season 1, Episode 3 "Kingdoms of the Moon"We come to learn how Vignette and Philo met, a grave secret he and Darius hold, and see the final days of the war.
Director(s) Anna Foerster
Writer(s) Travis Beacham
Air Date 8/30/2019
Introduced This Episode
Darius Ariyon Bakare
Mima Roosan Badria Timimi
  • The Young Woman Who Watches Over The Books: Mima Roosan, Vignette, Philo
  • The Secrets A Man Holds: Philo, Vignette, Darius
  • Was It The End Or A Long Pause?: Vignette, Philo, Tourmaline, Mima Roosan
Season 1, Episode 2 "Aisling"As a formerly famous pixie is found brutally murdered, Philo finds himself a new case as Vignette decides the Spurnrose household isn’t for her.
Director(s) Thor Freudenthal
Writer(s) René Echevarria
Air Date 8/30/2019
Introduced This Episode
Aisling Erika Starkova
Afissa Tracey Wilkinson
Absalom Jared Harris
Jonah Arty Froushan
Piety Indira Varma
Haruspex Alice Krige
Sylvanus Wil Johnson
Tourmaline Karla Crome
Dahlia Chlie Pirrie
  • A Missing Son: Absalom, Jonah, Piety, Haruspex
  • A Dead Pix: Aisling, Philo, Sylvanus
  • It’s Hard To Move Forward When You Keep Looking Back: Philo, Vignette, Ezra, Imogen, Tourmaline, Agreus, Dahlia
Season 1, Episode 1 "Some Dark God Wakes" [Series Premiere]Carnival Row may begin with a gorgeous, complex world with varied creatures, but the beauty fades when anything is put under a microscope.
Director(s) Thor Freudenthal
Writer(s) Travis Beacham, René Echevarria
Air Date 8/30/2019
Genre(s) Fantasy
Good If You Like
  • Shows With Large Worlds & Large Casts
  • Victorian Era Shows, With A Slight Steampunk Vibe
  • A Dash Of Romance, But It Not Likely Being The Selling Feature
  • Possibly Episodic Stories
Introduced This Episode
Rycroft Philostrate Orlando Bloom
Vignette Cara Delevingne
Portia Fyfe Maeve Dermody
Imogen Tamzin Merchant
Ezra Andrew Gower
Agreus David Gyasi
Unseelie Jack Matthew Gravelle
Season 1, Episode 5 "Grieve No More"The truth behind Philo’s parentage is revealed as things begin to come to a boil in Imogen and Absalom’s life.
Director(s) Andy Goddard
Writer(s) Ian Deitchman, Kristin Robinson
Air Date 8/30/2019
Introduced This Episode
Dr. Mornage Gregory Gudgeon
Runyan Simon McBurney
Young Philo Ilian Gergisak
Young Aisling Veronika Mackova
  • How Low Our Family Has Fallen: Ezra, Imogen, Agreus
  • Never Underestimate A Longerbane: Sophie, Jonah, Piety, Absalom
  • A Mother’s Lullaby: Young Aisling, Young Philo, Philo, Runyan, Dr. Mornage
Season 1, Episode 6 "Unaccompanied Fae"Philo reveals a secret which will cause many, including him, trouble. Which coincides with Sophie revealing her secret, and Imogen coming to a realization.
Director(s) Andy Goddard
Writer(s) Stephanie K. Smith
Air Date 8/30/2019
Introduced This Episode
Quill Scott Reid
Cabal Theo Barklem-Biggs
Sargent Dombey Jamie Harris
  • Pity Those Who Underestimate Us: Sophie, Absalom, Jonah
  • A World Of Treasures & A Shocking Realization: Vignette, Imogen, Agreus
  • Be Wary Of Who You Trust: Ms. Fyfe, Philo, Runyan, Afissa, Sargent Dombey
Season 1, Episode 7 "The World To Come"Philo’s father has been revealed, just as it seems he faces death, and Imogen seems to have picked up her father’s habits in sympathy for fae.
Director(s) Jon Amiel
Writer(s) Peter Cameron
Air Date 8/30/2019
Introduced This Episode
Constable Berwick Waj Ali
Magistrate Flute Mark Lewis Jones
  • Watch The World Burn & Be Part Of Its Rebuild: Runyan, Sophie, Jonah
  • Beauty & The Beast: Imogen, Agreus, Ezra
  • Does The Truth Ever Set A Person Free – Outside Of Their Mind?: Philo, Vignette, Ms. Fyfe, Sargent Dombley, Constable Berwick, Magistrate Flute
Season 1, Episode 8 "The Gloaming" [Season Finale]In the season finale, the controller of the Darkasher is revealed, as well as who the real mastermind behind the events of season 1.
Director(s) Jon Amiel
Writer(s) Travis Beacham
Air Date 8/30/2019
  • A Love Like This Does Not Come Every day: Imogen, Agreus, Ezra
  • Many Secrets Revealed: Piety, Absalom, Jonah, Sophie, Philo, Haruspex
  • The Prophecy Holds True: Jonah, Vignette, Philo, Sophie, Piety

How Would You Rate This?

Negative Mixed Positive

Subscribe To Our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
Email Format

Questions, Comments, or Opposing Opinion?

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.